diff --git a/04-ISSUES/051-the-mesh-cannot-update-what-it-depends-on/00-report.md b/04-ISSUES/051-the-mesh-cannot-update-what-it-depends-on/00-report.md index 37774f6..a701f06 100644 --- a/04-ISSUES/051-the-mesh-cannot-update-what-it-depends-on/00-report.md +++ b/04-ISSUES/051-the-mesh-cannot-update-what-it-depends-on/00-report.md @@ -62,6 +62,28 @@ legitimate provision and `lavinmq` is one provider of it. So adoption is not only an upgrade path. It is two rows of a mesh's module list becoming one, twice. +## And it is one SERVER each, not two + +**The broker duplication is running today, not just latent.** The lavinmq module raises its own +`server` container and points its provisioner at `http://lavinmq:15672` — a second LavinMQ, +separate from the substrate's `mesh-broker`. A mesh with the module assigned runs both. + +This is not how LavinMQ is meant to be used, and the module's own provisioner says so: a consumer +is given a *vhost* named for its login, isolated from every other consumer's by the vhost boundary +— *"the exact analog of postgres's database-per-login"*. One server hosts the mesh's own control +traffic on the `/` vhost and every consumer's broker as a vhost beside it. Two servers is the same +mistake as two postgres containers, wearing AMQP. + +So adoption means the lavinmq module does not run a `server` of its own. Its server IS the +substrate broker, adopted; the module contributes the provisioner, the tools, the event consumer +and the run-once bootstrap that configures it — all against the one broker. Same for postgres: one +server, the control plane's records in their databases and every module's database beside them. + +**The provisioner already assumes this** — it creates a vhost, not a broker — so the change is +removing the second server, not building a new isolation model. What has to be designed is only the +adoption itself: raising the one broker at genesis because nothing else can, then holding it as the +module, over the broker it is. + ## What makes this harder than it looks **The recursion is real, not incidental.** The control plane learns what modules exist by reading