hq/03-DESIGN/01-to-be/45-a-core-that-cannot-fail-silently.md

layer, status, code, updated, decisions

layer	status	code	updated	decisions
to-be	in-progress	mesh-controller mesh-host mesh-tools mesh-catalog mesh-sdk mesh-lab	2026-10-08	02-DECISIONS/0240-a-module-says-how-it-is-healthy-and-the-node-engine-judges-it.md 02-DECISIONS/0239-a-delivery-is-owned-by-the-mesh-delivery-module-and-runs-from-commit-to-delivered.md 02-DECISIONS/0238-a-commit-is-the-build-at-hand-one-commit-one-change-plan-checked-off-the-trunk-and-published-only-on-it.md 02-DECISIONS/0237-a-change-is-judged-against-the-mesh-that-runs-before-it-merges-on-the-build-seat.md 02-DECISIONS/0236-a-build-is-judged-on-its-first-machine-and-put-back-by-something-other-than-itself-and-so-it-rolls-out-unattended.md 02-DECISIONS/0234-the-mesh-holds-a-conversation-with-its-operator.md 02-DECISIONS/0233-a-module-declares-the-data-it-holds-and-the-mesh-protects-and-watches-it-from-that.md 02-DECISIONS/0227-the-core-holds-nine-rules-each-checked-and-is-built-to-them-in-six-phases.md 02-DECISIONS/0229-the-cores-order-is-a-lease-the-store-remembers-and-an-epoch-a-machine-is-sent-once-it-reads-one.md 02-DECISIONS/0231-a-healer-acts-on-what-observation-raised-and-only-observation-says-it-worked.md 02-DECISIONS/0230-a-consumer-the-mesh-stops-asking-for-is-retired-and-deleted-only-by-a-person.md 02-DECISIONS/0224-a-provider-that-keeps-failing-a-consumer-is-a-problem-the-controller-reports.md 02-DECISIONS/0218-a-plan-sends-grants-before-code-rolls-out-one-machine-first-and-a-newer-merge-takes-over-an-older-plan.md 02-DECISIONS/0141-the-host-delivers-its-own-successor.md 02-DECISIONS/0201-a-module-keeps-its-current-state-in-key-value-buckets-it-declares-and-reaches-through-the-runtime.md

45 — A core that cannot fail silently

The core says when it is wrong, refuses what is stale or unreadable, repairs what it knows how to repair, replaces itself one machine at a time with something other than itself watching, and is checked against the mesh's real facts before a change merges (ADR 0227, from research 031).

The core, here: the controller, the node-engine and its launcher, the bus server, the tool runner and the mesh MCP server, the build seat, and the forge's announcer of merges.

This document is the build's specification. §1–§9 are the parts; §10 is the order they are built in, each phase with what it delivers, in which repository, and when it is done. Every bound marked provisional is set from the durations Phase 0 records and corrected in Phase 1's first live week.

The parts, and how a fact reaches the operator

  signals ──────────► watchdogs ─┐                      ┌─► status (open conditions first)
  (heartbeats, reports,          │                      │
   plan progress, advisories)    ├─► CONDITION STORE ───┼─► condition events ─► operator-channel ─► Telegram
  doctor probes ─────────────────┤   (controller is     │                       holder             desktop notifier
  (live invariants, every 5 min) │    its only writer)  └─► healers ─► repair, braked ─► event
  events (provider failing, …) ──┘                                         │
                                                                           └─► hand-act log (people)

  second machine: watcher ── hears doctor's heartbeat? ── no, past bound ──► Telegram directly (not the bus)

Owning repositories: mesh-controller (the condition store, watchdogs, doctor, healers, the lease, calls, the hand-act log, the facts snapshot), mesh-host (the node-engine: the apply queue, report order, epoch refusal, the report verb, rollback witnessing), mesh-tools (the tool runner and the mesh MCP server: their heartbeat, passing every argument, health answers), mesh-catalog (the operator-channel seat's holder and channels, the watcher, the providers' retirement, the catalogue's merge gate), mesh-sdk (the TypeScript providers' loop and its retirement), mesh-lab (the replays and the induced-failure scenarios).

---

1. The writers table (rule 1)

Every kind of state the core keeps, and the one component that writes it. Anyone else asks.

State	Writer	Kept in	Others
a machine's declaration	controller (lease holder)	the bus, last per subject	read
a machine's applied state and its report	the node-engine's apply queue (§6)	the machine; the report on the bus	the reconcile and a delivery enqueue, never apply
the controller lease	the controller instance holding it	key-value mesh-controller_lease	a candidate waits
plans and their tiers	controller (lease holder), compare-and-set on the plan's revision	the controller's store	read through plans
conditions	controller	key-value mesh-controller_conditions, and their history mesh-controller_condition-history	raise or clear only through observations the controller reads
calls and their outcomes	controller	key-value mesh-controller_calls	read by id
the hand-act log	controller, through the verbs that act	key-value mesh-controller_hand-acts	—
the healers' acts and their brake	controller (lease holder), each act begun before it is made	the controller's store	read through healers; each act said as healer-acted and in its condition's tried
stream definitions and bus permissions	controller	the bus	—
builds and their outcomes	the build seat's holder	its own state	the controller asks
a merge announced	one announcer per forge (the hook, or the poll when the hook is absent — never both)	the bus	—
a pull request's head announced	the forge's announcer, the one that announces its merges	the bus	the controller asks the build seat to check it
a pull request's merge check	the build seat's holder that ran it, said as the controller's checked	the bus	the forge's holder sets it as the pull request's status
a provider's standing	the provider	the provider's events	the controller keeps the newest word as a condition
a consumer's retirement: active, retired (when, why), deleted	the provider	its own backend's mark; said on provisioner.retirement	the controller asks the provider's tools; a person approves, rejects and deletes through the controller's verbs
the operator-channel's open messages	the seat's holder	its own key-value state	—
a machine's declared data: what it measured, what is retired, what was deleted (ADR 0233)	controller, from what each node-backup holder answers	the controller's store, data_item and data_reading	the holder measures and says; it records nothing the controller keeps
the facts snapshot	controller	the artifact store, facts/latest	the build seat reads

A bus subject two components may publish on is refused when the controller composes grants, unless this table marks it shared. Changing a writer is a change to this table, through a decision.

How it is enforced (ADR 0229): the table is compiled into the controller, each row the bus carries with the subjects a write of it publishes to — a declaration mesh.node.*.declare, a report mesh.control.*.report (its own machine's only), the controller's buckets, stream creation, update and deletion and durable consumer creation, a build's outcome, a merge announced, a provider's standing — and its writer among the principals. A grant that overlaps another writer's subject is refused at composition, naming the state and its writer. A test holds the compiled table to this one, row for row. The controller does not publish mesh.control.>: it would be a second writer of every machine's report.

2. The condition store (rules 5, 6)

A condition is a durable fact about something the mesh owns that is wrong. It is raised and cleared by observation only.

Where. A key-value bucket, mesh-controller_conditions, written by the controller alone, one entry per open condition, with no age. Every transition — raised, changed, silenced, cleared — is also appended to a history kept ninety days in a bucket of its own, mesh-controller_condition-history, read through conditions history: a bucket has one age for every key, and an open condition must outlive the history.

The key names the thing and the kind, so the same fault said again is the same condition: <scope>.<id>.<kind>, where scope is one of machine, plan, call, build, merge, provider, seat, bus, core, probe, mesh. Examples of the shape: machine.<node>.silent, plan.<id>.stalled, provider.<module>.<node>.<consumer>.failing, core.controller.<node>.rolled-back, bus.<consumer>.slow-consumer. The last token is the kind's short word where it has one (failing for provider-failing), the kind elsewhere; a key is opaque to every reader, and the kind is the field.

Added 2026-10-07, ADR 0240: the scope module, for a module's own health on a machine — module.<module>.<machine>.unhealthy, raised by the controller on the second statement from the node-engine that a long-running resource is unhealthy, and cleared on the first that does not. Designed in to-be 48.

The fields:

Field	Holds
kind	the condition kind, from the signals table, the probe registry or an event kind
subject	scope, id, and the machine it concerns when there is one
severity	urgent (needs the operator now) or warning (when they can) — two levels, no more
summary	one line in the mesh's words
evidence	the newest observations, at most ten, each with its time
source	the signals-table row, probe or event that raised it
raised, last observed	times; and how many observations since raised
tried	each healer attempt: when, what, outcome
resolver	self (clears on observation), healer:<name>, operator, or agent
silenced	until when, by whom, why — empty when not silenced
epoch	the controller lease epoch that last wrote it

The life of one:

 (absent) ──observation past bound──► OPEN ──healer tries──► OPEN (tried += …)
                                       │  ▲                     │ budget spent
                                       │  └─ seen again ◄───────┘──► OPEN, resolver: operator, severity: urgent
                                       │
                         silence (verb, ≤ 7 days, reason, hand act) ──► OPEN, silenced (no messages)
                                       │
                       observation says resolved ──► CLEARED: entry removed, transition kept in history

• Nobody resolves a condition by hand. It clears when the signal returns or the probe passes.
• A condition cleared and raised again within ten minutes reopens with its count increased; it is not a new message.
• The verbs: conditions (open ones, filtered by scope, severity or machine), conditions show <key>, conditions silence <key> --for <duration> --why <text>, conditions history.
• The events, emitted by the controller on its own subjects: condition-raised, condition-changed (severity or resolver changed; not every observation), condition-cleared. The operator-channel's holder and any other surface consume them; the controller learns nothing about telling. Each carries the condition at the top level, with event, at, change (raised, reopened, severity, resolver, silenced, silence-ended, cleared), why, was, cleared and show beside it; a silence and its ending are condition-changed, a reopening condition-raised with change reopened.
• status lists open conditions first, urgent before warning, oldest first, silenced ones marked with their expiry. The all-well sentence requires none open, silenced included.
• ADR 0224's provider standing is the first kind: provider-failing, raised by the provider's event, cleared by its recovery, its silence after thirty minutes the row S8 below.
• Retirement (ADR 0230) raises three, keyed by the provider module and its machine: retire-waiting (urgent) while a stable set too large to retire alone waits for retire approve or retire reject, listing it; retire-rejected (warning) while a rejected set is kept active though the mesh no longer asks for it; and cleanup-waiting (warning), from the probe D11, while anything retired is older than thirty days. The first two clear on the provider's retired, settled or approved word, and all three when the provider is no longer assigned there.
• Data (ADR 0233) raises, from D13, each urgent for irreplaceable data and a warning for valuable data — the operator's ranking — and none for rebuildable data or caches: data-shrank (less than half its largest size in seven days, and 16 MiB less), data-missing, empty-replacement (a copy in use less than half a copy of the same thing kept elsewhere — issue 273's shape — for an item or for a consumer's data at a provider), data-quiet (an item that says active, unwritten past it), backup-stale, array-degraded (one per array under watched data) and protection-missing (an item said to be on redundancy, found on plain storage); and as warnings data-held-twice, data-unmeasured and cleanup-waiting for an item retired over thirty days. Keyed by machine, module and item, or by the array. A shrink a person meant is silenced with why; everything else clears on observation.

3. The signals table (rule 5)

Compiled into the controller. A watchdog per row; the test generated from the table suppresses each signal and asserts its condition. doctor signals shows, for every row, the age of its newest signal.

Row	Signal	Emitter	Trigger	Bound	Condition kind	Severity	Healer
S1	machine heartbeat	node-engine	its interval	3 × interval, provisional	silent — not raised while the machine has declared itself asleep or shut down (ADR 0211)	warning; urgent after 30 min for the control node	—
S2	report after a send	node-engine	each declaration sent	max(2 min, 3 × that machine's last apply duration), provisional	sent-not-reported	warning	H1
S3	plan tier progress	controller's plan	each tier entered	from the tier's build and apply durations, provisional	stalled (names the tier and what it waits on)	warning	H2
S4	the controller's event loop takes a message	controller	while its consumer has pending messages	2 min	controller-deaf	urgent	—
S5	a merge announced becomes a plan or nothing reads it	announcer → controller	each merge	10 min (exists, issue 266)	merge-not-acted	urgent	—
S6	a build asked → its outcome	build seat	each ask	max(20 min, 3 × the p90 of measured builds), 1 h while nothing is measured, provisional (the build seat declares no timeout)	ask-lost	warning	—
S7	a call running → finished	controller	each call	the verb's bound: push, rotate and command 30 min; assign and unassign 15 min; doctor 3 min; others 10 min	call-hung	warning	—
S8	a provider's failing word repeated	provider	every 15 min while failing (ADR 0224)	30 min	provider-silent	warning	—
S9	bus advisories: slow consumer, maximum deliveries, permission violation, consumer deleted	bus server's system subjects	any	any occurrence	slow-consumer, max-deliveries, refused, consumer-lost — each naming the call, consumer or module in the mesh's words	warning	H3 for consumer-lost
S10	the self-check's heartbeat	controller's doctor	every run	2 × its interval, watched from the second machine (§5)	self-check-silent	urgent	—
S11	tool runner heartbeat	tool runner	its interval	3 × interval, provisional	tools-silent	warning	—
S12	the controller lease renewed	controller	every 5 s	15 s; a holder that lost the lease or was found expired, and a lease bucket found raised again from nothing, said for an hour; a controller serving without the lease, while it does	lease-lost	urgent	—
S13	stale refusals	every receiver (rule 2)	each refusal	more than 5 from one writer in 5 min	stale-writer (names the writer: the controller epoch a refused declaration claimed, with its instance and how its lease ended; or the machine whose older accounts the controller refused)	warning	—
S14	facts snapshot exported	controller	when it moved, and daily	2 days, or none kept by a controller up that long (Phase 5)	facts-stale	warning	—
S15	a hand act with a cause already recorded	hand-act log	each act	the second within 14 days; clears when fewer than two remain within 14 days	healer-wanted (names the cause, and the healer that was not enough where one answers it)	warning	—
S16	a walk waiting for its delivery's word is let go	mesh-delivery, through deliver (ADR 0239)	each merge whose walk waits	30 min; urgent after 4 h	waiting (names the walk and plans go)	warning	—

The bus advisories (S9) cost one read-only subscription: the server already publishes them. The controller translates each into a condition naming the thing in the mesh's words, as the refused reply of issue 265 is translated today. An advisory clears after an hour without another; a deleted consumer is said only for one the mesh names and expects, and clears when it exists again. Until the bus has a system account the controller hears a slow consumer and a refused subject for its own connection only (issue 270, open question 2).

4. The self-check: doctor (rule 6)

A probe registry in the controller: each probe is a live invariant of a design, with an id, an interval, a timeout and the condition kind it raises. The controller runs the registry every five minutes; each probe has thirty seconds. A probe that errors or times out is said in that run's verdict at once — an unanswered probe is never a pass — and raises probe-failed for itself when the next run cannot run it either.

A finding one look can be wrong about is raised on the second look in a row (issue 277): a question over the network that went unanswered, a time measured once, a reading a burst can move. Within a run such a question is asked again before it counts; across runs the finding is raised when the previous run saw it too, kept while it is open however it is seen, and cleared by the run that no longer sees it. Held back, it is listed in the verdict as unconfirmed. A definite answer — an address that is wrong, a stream that is not there — is raised at once. The watchdogs hold a row that cannot read its facts to the same rule over two ticks. Checked by the controller's tests of the self-check over runs and of a blind row over ticks.

A condition's summary names machines and says the rest in words; an address, a domain, a path or a raw error is its evidence, which stays inside the mesh. The condition store holds every summary to the operator channel's content rule (ADR 0234 §6) and says one that would be withheld in words, keeping it whole in the evidence; a lint over every condition raised in the controller's test suite fails the producer that wrote it.

Probe	Asserts	From
D1	every machine's declaration composes, and passes the node-engine's validation (the validator is a package of mesh-host the controller and the merge gate import — one validator)	236, 263
D2	every holder of the mesh's resolver answers a machine name for IPv4, and NODATA for IPv6	262
D3	every seat on record has a live holder that answers (holder-silent, H3)	208, 218
D4	every kept archive is held by a manifest	253
D5	exactly one lease holder — the key names this controller at the epoch it acts under, and the controller's record holds no other epoch open; no message from a stale epoch refused in the last interval	204
D6	every durable consumer exists with its definition and is near its stream's head (within 1000 messages, provisional); a missing one is consumer-lost (H3), one far behind consumer-behind (H4)	248, 266
D7	every stream the controller defines exists with its definition	208
D8	no address the mesh owns is in a ban list	238
D9	status answers in full within ten seconds	265
D10	every machine runs the node-engine and tool runner builds its plan says, or is inside a plan's window	version split
D11	no provider holds a consumer retired more than thirty days: each provider assigned is asked provisioner_retirement on its machine (ADR 0230); one that does not serve it yet is named, not failed	ADR 0230
D12	every consumer of a provision that keeps its data is bound where it was last sent, or moves by a pin (binding-kept, binding-moving, binding-moved)	ADR 0232
D13	every item of data a machine declares is measured, is there, holds what it held, is written where it says it is, is backed up within its bound or sits on healthy redundant storage, and is no empty replacement of a copy kept elsewhere; an irreplaceable or valuable item a machine no longer declares is retired, not forgotten. Each machine's node-backup holder is asked backed-up; every provider of kept consumer data provisioner_retirement (with each held consumer's size) — see §2 for the kinds	ADR 0233, issue 273
DW	the watchdogs of §3 ran within three of their intervals: the watchers are watched, and raise S10 when the self-check stops	rule 6
H-*	the health probes of §8, run for every core component on every machine: H-controller, H-engine, H-tools, H-bus (as built, ADR 0236)	rule 8
DG	every build that failed its gate, and every core build a witness put back, is said — build.<module>.<machine>.rolled-back, core.<component>.<machine>.<outcome>, rollback-failed — until a newer build passes or the reports stop saying it (ADR 0236)	rule 8
DB	a bus upgrade a person started is said as bus-maintenance while it runs, and ends healthy within its bound or is said bus-upgrade-failed, with its snapshot (ADR 0236)	rule 8

• doctor answers the last run's verdict at once: per probe, pass, fail or failed-to-run, and age. doctor run runs now under a call id. doctor probes lists the registry; doctor signals the table's ages.
• Every run ends with a heartbeat event carrying the run's id and counts. That is S10.
• The registry is the design's live form. A check over the to-be designs counts invariants that name a probe against those that do not; the number without may only go down.

5. The output channel, minimal form (rule 6)

From research 028, the smallest form that works. Amended 2026-10-06 by ADR 0234, 028's graduation: this form is the first step of to-be 46, the conversation with the operator, which replaces the points marked below. Phase 1 builds this section; to-be 46 §13 builds what follows from it.

• One mesh seat, operator-channel, held once. It accepts notify as a work queue, so a message waits for a holder; it keeps its open messages in its own key-value state, so a restart forgets nothing; it serves open and history.
• The holder consumes the controller's condition events and decides what is sent. The controller calls nobody.
• Two channels: Telegram (a bot to the operator's chat) and the desktop notifier of the machine the operator is at. Amended: a channel is not a contribution to this seat. Each is the holder of a kind on the kinded benches channel and intake, a module of its own holding its own secrets, and this seat's holder becomes the router (to-be 46 §2, §3, §8).
• A message is: the condition's key, its subject (a machine's role, a module, a plan), kind, severity, the one-line summary, since when, and the verb that shows more. Deduplicated by the key.
• When: on condition-raised; once more if still open after 1 hour (urgent) or 12 hours (warning); on condition-cleared, by editing the first message where the channel can. A silenced condition sends nothing. Urgent goes to both channels; warning to the desktop notifier when the operator's session is there, otherwise to Telegram.
• Rate: at most twenty messages an hour; the excess is folded into one message naming them all.
• What may leave the mesh: roles and words. A message carrying an address, a path or anything shaped like a secret is refused by the holder and raises channel-refused instead. Amended: the mesh's own machine names may appear too; a concrete detail travels as a reference only a private surface opens, and a refusal names the offending part to the sender (to-be 46 §9).
• Answering back. Amended: the minimal form had none, and acknowledging was conditions silence, through the mesh. The operator now answers and is asked over the intake seat; an answer that performs an action is checked and performed by the controller (to-be 46 §5, §6, §10). conditions silence stays callable.
• The watcher's watcher. A module, mesh-watcher, assigned to one machine that is not the control node, holds the Telegram channel's secret too. It listens for the self-check heartbeat (S10) and for the bus itself; when either has been silent past its bound it sends to Telegram directly over HTTPS, not through the bus, and says so again when they return. It is the only sender that does not pass through the control node.

6. Order: lease, epoch, report sequence, one apply queue (rules 1, 2)

The lease. A controller instance acts — sends a declaration, writes a plan, a condition or a call — only while it holds the key holder in mesh-controller_lease: written with compare-and-set, a fifteen-second time to live, renewed every five seconds. The epoch is the bucket revision at which it was taken. A starting controller waits for the key to be absent or expired. One that fails a renewal stops acting at once and exits, so its service manager restarts it as a waiting candidate.

As built (ADR 0229):

• The gate is the clock. A holder stops acting three seconds before its key could expire unrenewed, whatever its renewing goroutine is doing; every act passes that gate at the moment it is made — a declaration at its send as well as where it was composed.
• The epoch never goes backwards. The controller's store keeps every epoch issued, its instance, and how it ended (released, lost, expired); a lease bucket at or under the highest is moved past it before the key is taken, and S12 says so.
• A holder that stops gives the key back, so the next takes it at once.
• Without the bucket's grant, nobody holding it, a controller serves unleased — no epoch on what it sends, S12 urgent — and takes the lease once the user list that grants it reaches the bus.
• A command at a shell acts under the holder's epoch, read as it acts, or under a lease of its own while nobody holds one.

 controller A (epoch 41)  ──renew──renew──╳ (renewal refused)──► stops sending, exits
 controller B             ──wait──────────────take (epoch 57)──► acts; marks A's running calls abandoned
 node-engine              accepts 41 … then 57; refuses anything from 41 after 57, counted, reported

What carries the order:

Message	Carries	The receiver keeps, per writer	Refuses
declaration	epoch, sequence	highest epoch, then highest sequence	older epoch; same epoch, lower sequence — only where both claim an epoch
report	machine, the declaration's epoch and sequence it is about, the node-engine's own report sequence (kept on disk, increasing across restarts and self-updates)	highest epoch where both claim one, then declaration sequence, then report sequence	an account of an older declaration; an older report
plan write	the plan's revision, the epoch	— (compare-and-set)	a write against a revision already moved
build outcome	the build's ask id and order	newest per module	an older build finishing later (exists, 219)
call	call id, epoch	—	a finish from an epoch that is not the holder's, recorded as abandoned
merge announcement	forge, repository, commit, the announcer's sequence	newest per repository	a duplicate (one announcer)

Every refusal is one line in the receiver's log in the mesh's words, a counter, and — from the node-engine — a report naming the refused declaration, so the controller sees it. The counter feeds S13.

The wire — the contract, written once on each side: a declaration's epoch and sequence are top-level keys of its signed envelope; a report carries back the epoch and sequence of the declaration it is about, its own report_sequence, older_than (the order held) on a refusal of an older declaration, and refused_older (how many ever) on every report. Every key is optional, zero is "no order claimed". A machine is sent epoch only while its latest account carried a report_sequence, because an older node-engine refuses an unknown key, whole; a declaration without an epoch is taken by its sequence, so a controller rolled back to a build without the lease is never stranded. A report without a report_sequence is judged by the digest it names (issue 267). What the mesh would send a machine is composed with the epoch it was last sent: a new holder is not a change of the machine.

One apply queue on every machine. The node-engine has one worker that applies; a delivery, the five-minute reconcile, a self-update hand-over and a manual apply are four reasons to enqueue. The queue holds at most one pending request, coalesced. When the worker starts it takes the newest declaration held at that moment, applies it once, and sends one report naming the sequence it applied. Nothing else in the node-engine applies.

The report verb. The node-engine answers, on request, the report of the last declaration it applied, from what it keeps on disk. It is what healer H1 asks. As built (ADR 0231): asked on mesh.node.<machine>.ask.report, its own only, the node-engine enqueues a reconcile whose account is said whether or not it is news — a delivery waiting is applied and reported instead — and the answer is its ordinary report; nobody's inbox is answered.

Durable calls. Every call's record — verb, arguments with secrets removed, caller, started, epoch, state (running, finished, failed, abandoned), the answer bounded in size, finished — lives in mesh-controller_calls, the last thousand or fourteen days. A new lease holder marks the previous holder's running calls abandoned, which is said.

7. Healers and the hand-act log (rule 7)

A healer is a registered response to one condition kind: its repair (the ordinary path again), its budget, its back-off, its brake, and the healer-acted event naming the condition, the act and the outcome. A healer may not withdraw, delete or recreate data; such a repair is a condition for the operator.

Healer	Condition	Repair	Budget, then
H1	sent-not-reported	ask the machine's node-engine for report; if it does not then report the declaration it was sent, send it again — never moving a build a policy or a plan holds back	twice per condition in 6 h, then resolver operator, urgent
H2	stalled on a wait that is superseded (a newer plan of its repository and branch) or already finished (every module built or failed, every one that rolls out sent)	close the plan with its note, as plans close does: superseded or done	once
H3	a seat holder that does not answer (D3, holder-silent), or a consumer the mesh expects missing (D6, S9, consumer-lost)	assert the bus's objects again — the assertion every send makes (208)	once per object per hour
H4	consumer-behind (D6) on a consumer the stream table marks resettable — the controller's own events consumer alone	broker consumer-reset (248)	once a day per consumer, then condition
H5	provider-failing with the administrator refusing the mesh's secret	ADR 0224 §5 (exists, in the module)	as ADR 0224

As built (ADR 0231): the registry is compiled into the controller with a test generated from it; each act is begun in the controller's store before it is made, under the lease, and the budgets are counted from there; a healer that does not apply to a condition leaves it alone; only observation says a repair worked — the act is kept in the condition's tried as healer Hn and said as healer-acted, and the condition clears when what raised it no longer sees it; a spent budget hands it to the operator, urgent, and no healer touches it again. The mesh-wide brake: twelve acts in an hour, all healers together, stop every healer — mesh.healers.braked, urgent — until an hour after the last. A heal is never a hand act. healers lists the registry, the acts and the brake.

The hand-act log. Every verb that repairs by hand — a named push outside a plan, plans close, broker consumer-reset, conditions silence, retire approve, retire reject and cleanup delete (ADR 0230; and an approval, rejection or deletion a provider reports that did not come through the controller), and hand-act record for an act done outside the mesh — takes a required --why and writes an entry: who, which verb and arguments, why, when, the condition key it addresses if any, and a cause (the condition kind, or a word the person gives). status shows the week's count. A cause recorded twice within fourteen days raises healer-wanted (S15) — except an act recorded by a verb that is a person's decision by design, which is no repair and never counts, whatever cause it gives. The controller keeps one table of the verbs that write the log, and each says whether it records a repair or a decision, and why: approving or rejecting a retirement and deleting what was retired (ADR 0230); bus upgrade, because the bus is never rolled by the mesh, and upgrade release-backlog, because after a failed walk the next opens only on a person's word (ADR 0236); and secret rotate when its cause is a leak (leaked-in-logs) — a person judges what was disclosed, one leak rotates several values, and a leak that recurs is a defect of the module that prints them, an issue against it, not a healer that rotates. A rotation for any other cause counts. A push by hand, plans stop and close, broker consumer-reset, conditions silence and hand-act record (an act outside the mesh, whose kind the mesh cannot tell) count; so does a verb the table does not list. The table's test finds every verb the controller records and fails on one it does not list. A healer-wanted already open for a decision clears on the next watchdog tick, as any condition its row no longer sees.

A drill is no repair. Something broken on purpose to see the mesh raise and clear it is recorded by hand-act drill (the seat's drill), cause drill, which the table lists as a person's decision; hand-act record refuses that cause, so a repair cannot pass for a drill by the word it gives (issue 292; checked by the controller's S15 tests).

A push of recorded builds is no repair. A build of a module whose upgrade policy records moves only by a person's push (ADR 0242), and that push is the word the policy asks for. So a push says what it was, read by the controller from what it carries and never from a word the person gives. It is a push of recorded builds when it names one machine, that machine's last send is known and its last report is no failure, and every build it moves records rather than rolls out: a held new build, or a recorded module's first build on a machine newly assigned it. The act is written with its kind and what it carried; the table lists a push of that kind as a person's decision, and S15 never counts it. Any other push by hand still counts (issue 301; checked by the controller's replay R301 and its tests of the rule).

Progressive insight — 2026-10-06. This paragraph said before: "except retire-waiting and cleanup-waiting: approving a retirement and deleting what was retired are a person's decision by design (ADR 0230), and no healer may take them over." The exception was keyed on two causes, and the first planned bus upgrades (two within a day, one recorded after the fact and one through bus upgrade) raised healer-wanted for bus-upgrade, as did two rotations after one leak for leaked-in-logs. What makes an act a decision is the verb that recorded it, not the word it gives as its cause, so the exception is read from the verbs. Nothing decided changes: ADR 0230's acts stay exempt, and pushes by hand — what roll-out by default (ADR 0236) exists to end — still count.

8. Staged core upgrades and rollback (rule 8)

Health, per core component, as probes in the registry (§4):

Component	Healthy when	Witness that rolls it back
controller	holds the lease within 60 s of starting; status answers in full within 10 s; doctor ran once	the node-engine on the control node, which keeps the previous controller build installed beside the new one and reads the lease bucket
node-engine	has reported its current declaration under its own build	its launcher (ADR 0141), which keeps the known-good
tool runner	announced, and answer a ping within 5 s	the node-engine, which keeps the known-good
bus	every stream and durable consumer present (D6, D7); a request/reply round trip from every machine	none — a planned step, below

The gate. ADR 0218's first machine for a core component is judged by that component's health probes passing three consecutive times over two minutes, within ten minutes of the apply. Only then do the other machines follow. "Reported applied" is not enough.

 merge ─► plan ─► first machine applies new build ─► health probes ×3 within 10 min?
                                                       ├─ yes ─► the rest follow, one tier at a time
                                                       └─ no ──► witness restores previous build
                                                                  ─► condition core.<component>.<node>.rolled-back (urgent)
                                                                  ─► plan halts that component, records why

• Every core upgrade leaves a record in its plan: component, first machine, from and to build, verdict, time to verdict, rolled back or not. Read through plans.
• A rolled-back build is not retried by the same plan. A newer merge makes a new plan.

As built (ADR 0236):

• Every walk is gated, not only the core's. A module is judged by its own health: it reported applied, no witness put it back, no condition was raised since its send about the machine or about the module there, and its tools are served on that machine where it has tools. Three healthy judgings at least forty seconds apart and two minutes after the send, within ten minutes of it. A policy of together is not gated.
• The rollback is the ordinary path once per build. The build is marked failed at its gate (never registered again, plans retry refuses it); the module's registered build goes back to the build the first machine ran before, still kept by ADR 0189; that machine is sent it. The verdict is written before the send. Said as build.<module>.<machine>.rolled-back (warning) or core.<component>.<machine>. rolled-back (urgent), rollback-failed (urgent, the operator's) when nothing could be put back, and as the event rolled-back.
• The witness, as built on the node-engine (mesh-host internal/witness/contract.go, the controller's half internal/lease/witness.go): the controller's is the lease alone — the holder on this machine, taken since the start, renewed within fifteen seconds, within sixty seconds of the start — and the tool runner' is their answer to the services protocol's ping within five seconds, within sixty. The controller's "status in bound, doctor ran once" is the controller's own word in the lease's value, which the gate reads and the node-engine does not: a controller that holds the lease and never becomes ready is put back by the gate sending the previous build. A witness says its verdict in rollbacks on every report while it stands; the controller raises core.<component>.<machine>.<outcome> from it — urgent for rolled-back, not-reversible, restore-failed and halted — and clears it with the first report without it.
• No build reaches a machine without a gate: a gated send carries and judges everything waiting on its machine; every other send — a plan's rest, a cascade, a healer's, a whole-mesh push — is refused or leaves the machine while a build no gate has seen waits there; a rebuild with the same artifacts and manifest is no move. What waits is moved by a walk, one machine at a time, the control node last, each judged; one that fails holds the next until upgrade release-backlog --why.
• A new controller that passes its gate sends the bus's machine the user list it composes, when that changed and nothing held back would go with it.
• The default policy is to roll (ADR 0236 §4); record stays where a module says why, keeps irreplaceable data, or is the bus.

The bus is a planned step. A bus upgrade is a maintenance step a person starts through the controller: the streams are snapshotted; a bus-maintenance condition is open for the step's duration; the bus is replaced; afterwards D6, D7 and the round trip must pass, or the step is reported failed and the snapshot is the way back. A step whose new version cannot be reverted (the bus's 2.10 → 2.11 is one) says so before it starts and runs only on a person's explicit word, recorded as a hand act. Whether the bus becomes a cluster that can be upgraded live is left to its own effort.

As built (ADR 0236): the verb is bus upgrade --why … --reversible|--irreversible; the snapshot is the bus machine's backup holder backing the bus module up now (ADR 0235), or one a person took and names with --snapshot-taken; the step's bound is fifteen minutes; no send reaches the bus's machine while a new bus build waits for it — a push, a plan's send for another module, a healer's — after a plan's send restarted the bus unasked on 2026-10-06; a change of the bus's user list is reloaded in place, not a restart. 2026-10-06: the snapshot and the way back from it exist — the bus image's own snapshot program, the same one the night's backup runs, and a restore that builds a new store beside the live one for a person to swap in (ADR 0235, to-be 43).

9. Before merge: facts and replays (rule 9)

The facts snapshot. The controller exports daily, and after any change of machines, assignments or seats: every machine (a stable pseudonym of the same length as its name, its role, operating system, C library, architecture, node-engine and tool runner builds), assignments, settings keys and their non-secret values, seats and their holders, the catalogue commit, and the versions the mesh runs of the bus server, the store and the node-engine. No secret and no address: an address is replaced by one from a documentation range. It is kept in the artifact store as facts/latest, where the build seat reads it.

The merge gate. In mesh-controller, mesh-host and mesh-catalog, a check composes every machine of the snapshot with the change applied and runs the node-engine's validator over each. A change that makes any machine fail to compose or validate fails its check, naming the machine's role and the module. The resolver module's tests run under both C libraries the snapshot lists. A test in each core repository asserts that a pinned dependency's version equals the version the snapshot says runs.

Revision, ADR 0238 (2026-10-06). The commit is the build at hand. A commit off its module's trunk is only checked; a commit on it is published and pushed, and the controller refuses to register a build of one off it. The module graph, not the repository, decides what a pull request's check runs: every pull request the forge holds is announced, and the controller asks the planner — the one function that maps a changed file onto modules, and the one answer of what a merge moves and builds — what a merge of the head would reach. A changed file touches exactly the modules whose build reads it; a file no build reads touches nothing. A change reaching a module, or adding one, runs the gate on the build seat (mesh/merge-gate): the touched manifests through module check, failing only what the change brings; every machine composed with the definitions of the modules the plan moves or adds; the replays. Every repository of the mesh runs its own merge-check.sh (mesh/repo-check) in the toolchain it declares. A repository in two languages declares each further part of its check and the toolchain that part runs in, and the build seat runs each part in that toolchain's own container: the layer passes only when every part does (issue 302; checked by the builder's TestARepositoryInTwoLanguagesIsCheckedInBoth). A repository with none has "no repository check defined", a success where the branch does not require mesh/repo-check and a failure for a person where it does. A note is never a warning on a required status: the forge combines warning as a failure, so a note — a wide rebuild, a problem already so on the base — is a success that says it, and only what a person must decide fails (issue 293; checked by the forge module's status tests). The check's result is the commit's delivery plan — the build plan, the deploy plan machine by machine with what is not an ordinary send, and the verdict — posted on the pull request. The plan is one object with a state machine, kept, followed by the release and written to the commit as a note; which parts are built is Phase 5's.

The replays. mesh-lab carries a scripted scenario for each core incident, asserting the rule's outcome, run on every merge to mesh-controller, mesh-host and mesh-tools:

Replay	Incident	Asserts
R1	two controllers at once (204)	the second waits; nothing from the stale epoch is applied
R2	a reconcile due during a push (257, 261, 267)	one apply, one report, the newest sequence
R3	the node-engine self-updates during its report (230, 264)	the report arrives under the new build
R4	the bus's authorization reloads during a call (265)	the call's outcome is readable by id
R5	a consumer with several filter subjects under mixed traffic (266)	no announcement is skipped; S5 fires if one is
R6	an unreadable contributions file (241)	refused by name; nothing retired; a condition
R7	the controller rebuilds itself mid-plan (214)	the plan continues under the new epoch
R8	a broken controller, node-engine and tool runner build	each rolled back with no hand; condition and message
R9	each signal of §3 suppressed	its condition within its bound, cleared on return

A new core issue resolves with its replay added, or with a stated reason none is possible. The live mesh stays the test bed (ADR 0149): a replay covers what must not be done to it on purpose, and every rule keeps a live check.

As built (ADR 0237):

• The snapshot is composed every ten minutes and kept as facts:latest when it moved or is a day old; the one it replaced is let go of, so the store keeps one. It carries, beyond the list above, each machine's roles in words, its reported capabilities, pins, settings, the names of secrets a person gave, and how its declaration composes today; every module the mesh holds as its manifest, with its source and build edges. facts, facts compose, facts export.
• The gate is the controller's merge-gate: the mesh as the snapshot says it is and the mesh with the change, each raised in a throwaway store through the controller's own records and every machine composed twice and validated; what composes in the first and not the second is the change's. It also fails a manifest the judging controller cannot read (version skew), a consumer left out of a grant, a module removed while a machine runs it, two definitions of one name, a stored setting the change cannot keep, and a new module the node-engine would refuse on the first machine that could run it; it warns when a merge would rebuild more than twelve modules, saying when shared code is why (issue 278).
• It runs on the build seat, asked by the controller when the forge's announcer says a pull request's head moved: the repository's own merge-check.sh in the mesh's Go toolchain with no container runtime socket, beside a throwaway store and bus of the versions the snapshot says run, then mesh-lab's replays. The verdict is the head commit's status mesh/merge-gate, an error never a pass. A catalogue change is judged by the controller the mesh runs; a node-engine change by it built with the change's validator.
• Replays live where their incident is: a component's logic in its repository as TestReplay<issue>, what the mesh runs (the bus's release, the resolver under musl and glibc) in mesh-lab's replays/, all named in its register and proved by replays/cmd/prove. A core issue opened from 2026-10-07 resolves only with replay: or replay-none: (cycle.py).
• The controller's tests run a bus of their own per test, linked in at the release the mesh runs and held to it by a test, so the suite runs in parallel and under the race detector.

---

10. The phases

Ordered by risk removed per day: detection first, because it covers every class including those not met yet. A phase is done when its done when holds; this section records the date when it does.

Phase 0 — Finish what is in flight

Repository	Delivers
mesh-controller	the located fixes of 244, 265, 266, 267 rolled out; calls moved into mesh-controller_calls; status answered from a summary the event loop keeps current, inside ten seconds; the hand-act log with --why on the repairing verbs and hand-act record; recording the durations the bounds come from (apply duration per machine, heartbeat gaps, plan tier durations, build durations)
mesh-host	the fixes of 264 and 257/261 rolled out to every machine
mesh-tools	the mesh MCP server passing a mesh seat's node (244) rolled out
mesh-catalog	the bus's 2.10 → 2.11 upgrade, done as the first planned bus step by hand (snapshot, announced, checked after), recorded as a hand act

Done when: the four located core issues resolve with their live checks; a controller restart keeps every call's outcome; status answers in full within ten seconds five times in a row; the hand-act log has a week of entries; the durations are recorded for every machine.

Phase 1 — The mesh says when it is wrong

Repository	Delivers
mesh-controller	the condition store, its verbs, history and events (§2); ADR 0224's standing moved into it; watchdogs for S1–S11 and S13 with bounds set from Phase 0's durations (S12 is Phase 2's, S14 Phase 5's); the bus advisories subscribed and translated (S9); doctor with D1–D4, D6–D10, DW and its heartbeat (§4; D5 is Phase 2's); status led by open conditions; the test generated from the signals table
mesh-host	the heartbeat carries its interval; D1's validator published as a package the controller imports
mesh-tools	the tool runner's heartbeat (S11)
mesh-catalog	the operator-channel seat and its holder; the Telegram channel and the desktop notifier contributing to it; mesh-watcher on a machine other than the control node (§5)
mesh-lab	R9: each signal suppressed in turn

Done when: on a lab mesh, suppressing each signal raises its condition within its bound and sends a message; restoring it clears both. Stopping the controller makes the watcher send self-check silent within twice the self-check's interval. Live: a week of conditions read back, every one real or its bound corrected in the table.

Phase 2 — Order and one writer

Repository	Delivers
mesh-controller	the lease and epoch (§6); plans written by compare-and-set; a report kept by sequence; abandoned calls marked; S12, S13, D5; the writers table enforced at grant composition; contract tests for every consumed subject and the check listing them; the empty-on-error lint
mesh-host	one apply queue; the report sequence kept on disk; epoch refusal reported; the report verb; the contract tests and lint
mesh-tools	refusing an unreadable or unknown input by name; the lint
mesh-catalog, mesh-sdk	retirement in the providers' loop (ADR 0230, replacing ADR 0229's brake): a consumer no longer asked for is retired — disabled, marked, its data kept; or, by a provider that cannot disable, only marked, its access kept — only once the same result holds for five passes and ten minutes; remove is never called to retire; a set of more than three, or more than half of those held, waits for a person and raises a condition; the four retirement tools on every provider
mesh-lab	R1, R2, R6

Done when: R1 ends with nothing from the stale epoch applied, R2 with one report of the newest sequence, R6 with nothing retired; every consumed subject has its contract test.

Built 2026-10-06 (ADR 0229): the controller's lease and epoch, plans by compare-and-set, accounts kept by order, S12, S13 by writer, D5, the writers table enforced at composition, a contract for every consumed kind, the empty-on-error lint; the node-engine's one apply queue, report order and epoch refusal; the withdrawal brake in the Go providers' loop and the SDK's. Not yet: the replays R1, R2 and R6 in mesh-lab; mesh-tools' refusals and lint; the lint in mesh-host; the SDK's loop announcing a provider's standing, without which its brake is said in its journal only.

Amended 2026-10-06 (ADR 0230, the operator's decision): the brake's hourly release is replaced by retirement — three states (active, retired, deleted), five stable passes and ten minutes before a consumer is retired, a provider that cannot disable marking only (every TypeScript provider today), a person for more than three or more than half, retire approve|reject, cleanup list|delete, retirement events and D11. Built on branches in mesh-catalog (both Go providers), mesh-sdk (0.1.12) and mesh-controller, not yet merged. Not yet: the TypeScript providers giving their adapters a retire that disables (until then each is mark-only: its retired consumers keep their access), passing their module name and an announcer to the loop, without which a set over the bound there waits with no way to approve it, and adapters that list and delete what they retired.

Phase 3 — Healers

Repository	Delivers
mesh-controller	the healer registry and H1–H4, each braked and said; S15
mesh-lab	an induced failure per healer

Done when: a lab mesh recovers from each induced failure with no hand, says so, and brakes after its budget. Live: a week with no cause repeated in the hand-act log.

Built 2026-10-06 (ADR 0231): the healer registry and H1–H4 in the controller, H5 registered as the provider's own; the mesh-wide brake; healer-acted; healers; S15 live; the node-engine's report verb. Each healer's induced failure runs in the controller's tests against a real store, and H3 and H4 against a real bus: induced, repaired, cleared by the probe's own next run, and handed to the operator after the budget. Not yet: the induced failures on a lab mesh (mesh-lab), and so the phase's done when; the live week.

Amended 2026-10-06 (ADR 0233, the operator's decision, before Phase 4): a module declares the data it holds; D13 and its conditions; the data verb; cleanup extended to a module's own retired data, deleted by the machine's backup holder after a last restore point; the controller's grant names node-backup.backed-up. Built on branches in mesh-controller (migration 0072), mesh-host (the installer's user list; the kept-directory report), mesh-catalog (the holder's measuring and deletion, every module's data, the providers' held sizes), the media catalogue and the photo application, not yet merged. Not yet: the TypeScript providers saying their consumers' sizes (until then a consumer at two of them is data-held-twice, a warning, not compared), and SMART read under an array.

Phase 4 — Core upgrades that roll back

Repository	Delivers
mesh-controller	the health probes of §8; the gate on a core component's first machine — as built, on every plan's first machine (ADR 0236); the upgrade record in the plan; the bus maintenance step as a verb; the default upgrade policy roll (ADR 0236)
mesh-host	keeping the previous controller and tool runner builds; restoring one when its health is not met in bound, watching the lease bucket for the controller
mesh-tools	answering the health ping
mesh-lab	R3, R7, R8

Done when: on a lab mesh, a broken build of the controller, the node-engine and the tool runner — one that starts and does nothing, one that crashes, one that cannot reach the bus — is each rolled back with no hand, the mesh ends on the previous build, and a condition and a message say so. Live: the next three core builds to roll out each record a health verdict.

Built 2026-10-06 (ADR 0236, the operator's "start phase 4"): in mesh-controller (migration 0073), the probes H-controller, H-engine, H-tools, H-bus, DG and DB; the gate on every plan's first machine, its record in the plan (plans <id>) and in the store; the rollback by the ordinary path, once per build; the witnesses' verdicts as conditions; the grants the witness reads; bus and bus upgrade; the default policy roll, upgrade listing every module's policy and where it comes from; the user list carried after a controller passes; a module deleted at its source forgotten, not built. In mesh-host, the witness (keeping the previous controller and tool runner, restoring one not healthy in bound, the launcher's for the node-engine) and the installer's grants. In mesh-catalog, the modules that keep record say why, and the forge's announcer says which files a merge deleted. On branches, not yet merged. Not yet: R3, R7, R8 on a lab mesh, and so the done when; container state in the node-engine's report, without which a container that crash-loops after its compose applied is seen only through what it breaks; (designed 2026-10-07 by ADR 0240 as to-be 48, whose phases track it) composing not-reversible for a build whose migration cannot be undone; the verdicts of the next three core builds to roll out.

Phase 5 — Checks before merge, and the replays

Repository	Delivers
mesh-controller	the facts snapshot and S14
mesh-controller, mesh-host, mesh-catalog	the compose-and-validate merge gate; versions tested as run; the resolver's tests under both C libraries
mesh-lab	R4, R5 and the rest of the window's incidents; running the replays on every core merge

Done when: the replays of 236, 262, 263 and 266 fail on the commit before their fix and pass after; a new core issue cannot resolve without a replay or a stated reason.

Built 2026-10-06 (ADR 0237, the operator's "start Phase 5"), on branches, not yet merged: in mesh-controller the facts snapshot and S14, merge-gate, the check asked of and run by the build seat, merge-check.sh, the replays of 263 and 273, and a bus per test at the mesh's release; in mesh-catalog the forge's announcer of pull requests' heads and the verdict as their status, and merge-check.sh; in mesh-host merge-check.sh and the grants in the installer's user list; in mesh-lab the replays of 262 and 266, the register and the prover; in hq the replay rule in cycle.py. The prover ran the replays of 236, 262, 263, 266 and 273: each fails on the commit before its fix (236's check did not exist there) and passes on it. Not yet: R4, R5 and the rest of the window's incidents as replays; the merge gate's first runs against the live mesh's snapshot; the status required to merge, which is the operator's setting on the forge; mesh-tools' and mesh-sdk's merge-check.sh.

Revised 2026-10-06 (ADR 0238, the operator's "enable the checks on every repository of the mesh", "the logic acts on our module graph" and "the commit is the build at hand"), on branches, not yet merged:

Repository	Delivers
mesh-controller	the planner's one mapping of a changed file onto modules and its one answer of a merge's reach, asked by the merge handler, the what-if, the gate and the check; a file no build reads touches nothing (issue 280's left open); every pull request answered — the gate when it reaches a module, the repository's own check for the mesh's repositories, a pass that says so otherwise; the gate run by the build seat with its judge chosen from the graph, composing the plan's definitions only, failing only a manifest problem the change brings; the delivery plan computed and carried with the verdict; a build of a commit off its module's trunk recorded and never registered; its own manifest naming every verb of its seat
mesh-catalog	the forge's announcer saying, with every pull request, the directories holding a module at its head, the files it deletes and whether it has a merge-check.sh; both statuses and the delivery plan on the pull request; gitea_branch_protection_get and gitea_branch_protection_set; the catalogue's own check
mesh-host, mesh-tools, mesh-sdk, mesh-lab, mesh-media-catalog, and the applications built from their own repositories	each its own merge-check.sh; mesh-tools' tests each on a bus of their own
mesh-tools-go, mesh-tools	a C compiler and Python in the Go toolchain, git in the TypeScript one
hq	its own merge-check.sh, running records.py, index.py and cycle.py

Not yet: the delivery plan kept (id, inputs, result) and the release comparing its plan with it; the state machine replacing the walks' states, with its table, its test, its conditions and healer H2; the status's link to the kept plan; the notes under refs/notes/mesh-plan; check builds in a scratch namespace (the check builds no module today, so there is none to keep apart yet); the statuses made required — prepared as calls of the forge module's tool, applied by the operator.

Given an owner 2026-10-06 (ADR 0239): the state machine, the notes and the status's link are built as a delivery's, owned by the module mesh-delivery. They are designed in to-be 47, and their progress is tracked there.

What is not decided here

• The bus as a cluster of three, to upgrade it live.
• Routing by presence, quiet hours, answering back through a channel, and an external dead-man service — decided by ADR 0234, designed in to-be 46.
• A condition that needs judgement handed to an agent as work — research 017.