jschoubben
daf3e17c32
The identity provider is settled as not-substrate: the mesh does not require one, tier 2 authenticates natively, and it is a hosted service like any other. Four substrate services, not five. The tier test's second step gains the verb that matters — can the control plane START without it, not function fully without it. That verb answers the forge and the registries. They are not substrate and they are not duplicated: the control plane starts and manages nodes without a forge, it just cannot change itself. One gitea module, tier 4, and the mesh's own instance is distinguished by what it is bound to rather than by being a different module — the same answer as postgres, from the same test. It also buys a property worth having: if the forge dies the mesh keeps running. Delivery needing them is not an upward dependency, resolved the way the constitution already says to: tier 2 declares requirements, tier 4 provides implementations, the binding is data. The mechanism is provisioning, and the new idea is that the control plane is itself a consumer. Self-hosting therefore becomes a state the mesh REACHES, not a precondition. A first node comes up from pinned external artifacts and re-binds to internal providers once they exist. Today's mesh assumes the second state from the first moment, which is why the first-node path needs a script that papers over an impossibility and is the least-exercised code in the system. Made explicit, the transition is also reversible. Research 007 and 008 opened for the two areas flagged as important and complex, scoped from the weaknesses the as-is layer already documents rather than started blank. And the origin: this began as a dotfiles repository. The first two days adopt dotfiles, add per-node overrides, and introduce service symlinking with an ignore file. The flat one-directory-per-tool catalogue, linking over copying, adoption of already-configured machines, per-node overrides and the desktop modules are all inherited rather than chosen for a mesh. That is the single most useful fact for anyone changing the catalogue, it strengthens ADR 0018 — the case for links was never made for a mesh — and it explains research 005's silent fifty: dotfiles-era entries for one tool never shared a domain because they never had one.
03-DESIGN
The authoritative specification. Implementation is built against what is written here.
Two layers
| Folder | What it is |
|---|---|
00-as-is/ |
The mesh that exists today. Shipped behaviour, described as it is — including behaviour nobody would choose again. |
01-to-be/ |
The mesh being built toward. Every statement traceable to a record in 02-DECISIONS/. |
They are never mixed. A statement about the future does not belong in an as-is document, and an as-is document is never edited to describe an intention.
When a to-be design ships, it does not move. Its as-is counterpart is written or updated,
the to-be document's status becomes implemented, and both stand — one describing what runs,
the other recording what was intended. Deleting the intention loses the reasoning, which is
the expensive half.
Frontmatter
Every design document (not the READMEs) carries:
---
layer: as-is | to-be
status: designed | in-progress | implemented | abandoned
code: [] # owning code repo(s), from 00-META/repos.md
updated: YYYY-MM-DD # date of the last status change, not of text edits
decisions: [] # 02-DECISIONS/ records this document rests on
---
For an as-is document, status: implemented is the normal state — it describes something that
runs — and code: names where that implementation lives.
Status changes when implementation state changes, never because design text was edited. An
implemented claim must be defensible from the owning repository's main branch, not from
intent. If it cannot be checked, it is in-progress.
Cross-cutting views are generated from this frontmatter by the hal-status skill and never
written to disk.
What belongs here
Functional analysis, architectural description, and specification — prose and diagrams
only, no code. A manifest field may be named; a manifest may not be pasted. A document
enters the to-be layer only after the decision behind it is recorded in 02-DECISIONS/
and the research that produced it is closed.
Subfolders are encouraged where a layer grows enough to need them.