The lab was designed around a module under test, with a scenario being a
complete mesh — forge, coordinator, cascade, verify. That is unusable for
building the new mesh, because all four are tier 2 and do not exist yet.
And research 009 had the sequence backwards. It placed the lab at phase B
as verification of tiers already built, but tier 0 is the component that
takes over a machine's packages, services and network. It cannot be
developed against a machine anyone needs. The lab has to exist before the
thing it will test.
ADR 0029 splits scenarios into two classes. The bootstrap scenario is
virtual machines, the host binary and a pinned bundle, with the verdict
coming from what the host reports about the state it reconciled. The full
scenario is the designed one. The first is a strict subset of the second —
same virtualisation, same networking, same lifecycle, stopping before a
control plane exists — so the second is reached by addition rather than
rework.
The consequence worth having: raising a node from nothing stops being the
least-exercised path in the system and becomes the inner development loop.
It also settles the runner's two jobs. Scenario lifecycle is needed
immediately, because something must materialise and reset a mesh before
anything can be written against it. Assertion execution waits for the full
scenario.
Corrects a stale claim in the design while amending it: it argued
scenarios were affordable with system containers and would not be with
virtual machines. ADR 0016 superseded that reasoning and the text had not
followed.
Issue 007: the lab's first requirement is installed and unusable. The
virtualisation package is present and explicitly installed; both units are
disabled, the operator is in no group, and the client reports the server
unreachable. Not issue 001 again — that is an install failing while
reporting success. This is an install succeeding when success was not the
point. A package is files; a capability is a running service and an
identity permitted to reach it, and the module model has no vocabulary for
the second.
jschoubben
b4904fec7e