Two lines of work renamed the same seats differently. The trunk named them for their
scope — node-scoped ones `node-*`, leaving `the-artifact-store`, `npm-package-registry`
and `git` as they were — and this branch had renamed ten of them to `mesh-*`. The trunk's
set is what the live controller loads and what the live seats were actually renamed to, so
a manifest claiming this branch's name is one the running mesh refuses. Three of them
needed reverting by hand: git had auto-merged this branch's names where the trunk had not
touched those lines, which is the quiet kind of merge result.
Event names are this branch's, because the trunk has not converted them and they are what
issue 127 was about.
Verdaccio goes with the trunk's removal of it. The template work on dnsmasq's roster fact
is the trunk's, sitting beside this branch's local event names in the same file — the one
hunk where both changes landed together.
75 manifests, all parsing, no claim outside the trunk's set and no event name left in the
old bus's form.
Every module named its events the way the old bus spelled a routing key —
`module.<module>.<verb>`. Design 29 says a module names an event locally and the
mesh works out where it lands, so all 37 were stale against a rule already
decided. On the new bus that derives into a namespace belonging to a module
called "module", so no cross-module subscription in the mesh matched anything:
nothing failed, nothing reacted (novox/hq 04-ISSUES/127).
36 manifests converted, and 43 files of module code with them. The code mattered
as much as the manifests: the runtime builds the subject from what `emit()` is
handed, so a converted manifest with unconverted code would have had the
permission and the subject disagree.
Three things the new check found on the way:
- `photos` emitted an event its manifest never declared, which the new bus refuses
outright. Declared.
- `showcase` waited for an event nothing emits, so its demo could never be
triggered — only `showcase` may publish under its own name. It emits both halves
now.
- `distribution` declared an event named after a different module. It emits
`image.pushed` under its own name. An event about a *role* belongs on the seat,
where the name outlives whoever holds it, but the sdk has no way to publish on a
seat yet, so that stays recorded rather than declared.
The audit logger's "everything" pattern is `**` rather than the old bus's `#`.
The stated path was the adopted-data exception; with the take done and
the placement vocabulary live, the exception has no reason left. The
landing window renames the directory and recreates the container, since
a changed volume path does not do that by itself (hq 126).
ALTER USER ... WITH LOGIN runs only when the user's SID is not the
login's, so an already-mapped user is left alone. The provisioner
enables a mailbox through its own method; the password tool an
operator uses keeps changing the password only.
create re-enables what holds refuses (mssql login, mosquitto client,
mailu mailbox, gitea user) and clears an expired postgres password, so
no disabled account loops. mssql and mongodb checks take the password
from the environment, never argv; mosquitto_ctrl failures no longer
repeat -P. mosquitto reads 'could not ask' as an error, not absence.
mailu checks existence and enabled only: its imap passdb cannot verify
a password. mssql checks the user's SID; gitea pages teams at 50.
holds() for postgres, mssql, mongodb, minio, lavinmq, mosquitto, mailu
and gitea, so the harness makes again a login the backend lost (hq issue
120). Each checks the mesh's password as the consumer presents it, or
compares it read-only, and returns false only when the backend says the
credential is absent or wrong; an unreachable backend throws.
hq issue 091, measured 2026-09-22: 14 of 46 modules with containers fix the
machine side of a published port in their own manifest -- a fact about one
machine (which port HAL happened to publish it on) written into a
definition meant for any node. ADR 0038 already says the mesh assigns the
machine side and a module says only what it needs; the machinery already
does it (internal/inventory/ports.go's PortFor, declaration.go's
publishedOn rewrites a bare port automatically). These 14 just never
complied.
Fixed 11 of them -- stripped to the bare software port, letting assignment
take over: de-spiegel, gitea, hello-web (the demo module), mailu, mssql,
n8n, novox.be, only-office, photos, photos-eef, photos-filip.
Left alone, the two defensible kinds the issue names: postgres/lavinmq/
distribution (foundation, genesis-rewritten per ADR 0100 -- the number in
the manifest is a default, not a claim) and unifi (protocol/
device-discovery fixes the number; nothing else can find the controller).
gitea was a live one, not just a tidiness fix: its manifest said 2222:22,
but the actual adopted, running container is on 222. Harmless while held,
but the next 'take' would have recreated it on the wrong port and broken
SSH git access. Recorded 222 as novox's own setting for it (settings set
gitea -node novox) so that doesn't happen.
Read against hal/modules/mssql: the predecessor publishes 4848:1433 and its connections
block hands every consumer localhost:4848; its data has lived in /services/mssql/data
since it was installed — 4.6 GB of it. The nox module had 1433, db-data, and a pin three
builds behind, so taking it would have moved the port every consumer was told about,
started on an empty directory, and downgraded the engine at the same time.
db-data was not a convention: only this module and mongodb used it, and both predecessors
say data. Now nothing moves at the cutover.
From the survey of every env-file secret (ADR 0086, issue 041): amqp-ping,
minio, mongodb and grafana use the _FILE twin their software honours;
mesh-catalog and model-usage read DATABASE_URL_FILE (a file the mesh
templates, mounted where only the runtime reads it); grafana's secret files
belong to its own account. Two dead deliveries removed: a line nothing read
in amqp-email-forwarder, and mailu's secret.env on four containers that
never read it. The 25 exceptions that remain carry the surveyed reason —
convertible and awaiting a bed, convertible through a generated config file,
the application's own code, or not convertible.
ADR 0086. mesh-controller mounts its six own secrets and names them with
_FILE twins, so no credential of its own reaches its environment. The 35
containers that still read a secret through an env-file carry
secrets-in-environment with the reason; converting each where its software
accepts a path is the per-module work of issue 041.
keycloak, mailu, minio, mongodb, mssql, nextcloud, portainer, redis,
umami and verdaccio get the Dockerfile + build section the eight
buildable modules already had; their runtime containers name the
artifact instead of a placeholder digest.
One convention, settled (060's open question, informed by 061): the
runtime container runs serve mode with every serve-time entrypoint in
MESH_TOOL_MODULES — tools serve, events flow, and a provider's
provisioner reconciles in the same process with the broker connected.
postgres, gitea and lavinmq are retrofitted from args-run provisioners,
which served no tools and emitted lifecycle events nowhere.
route-proxy is deferred: its build context is the mesh-controller
repository, a cross-repo shape the build section cannot yet express.
Mirrors the proven catalog patterns field-for-field:
- lidarr -> the Servarr twin of radarr/sonarr (API v1, artist content); no
provisioner (it is a consumer app).
- mongodb -> postgres shape: mongodb-database provider, provisioner mints a
per-consumer db+user (ADR 0053), client shells to mongosh (no npm driver,
the psql convention).
- mssql -> postgres shape: mssql-database provider, sqlcmd client.
- mosquitto -> redis shape: mqtt-topic provider via the Dynamic Security
plugin, deliberately avoiding hal's password_file (that file is nox issue
011 exactly); provisioner mints a per-consumer MQTT client+role.
All four typecheck (strict, NodeNext) against the built @novox/mesh-sdk, and
their service images are digest-pinned to resolved registry digests. The
mesh-runtime-<mod> images keep the all-zeros placeholder the pipeline pins,
as postgres/redis do, and must bundle each module's CLI (mongosh/sqlcmd/
mosquitto_ctrl) as mesh-runtime-postgres bundles psql.
Not yet lab-verified: each module lists in-code what an integration test must
prove (auth model, provisioner reconcile, mosquitto dynsec bootstrap ordering).
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
jschoubben
jochen