mesh-grants moves to the same mesh-sdk (3203358c), so its shadow user list grants the checker and the builder the
DEAD_LETTERS reads the controller's list will, and the take-over is not blocked by a difference. The checker and the
builder hear DEAD_LETTERS through buildrun.DeadLetterHearing: in the background, again at every reconnect and every ask
waited for while deaf, and keep whether they hear it in their new state hearing, which checker_status and builder_stuck
say as dead_letters. checker_try says that a try ended by the not-taken bound leaves its ask in the stream.
Not done as asked: a module health tool. The catalogue refuses a tool check on a module with no runtime of its own and no
other check beside it (ADR 0227 rule 8, ADR 0366 §1), so the deaf state is said in the status tools and the log.
The bus node can only take over a list that exists: each pass composes the accounts block with the vault's hashes, seals
it to the key the bus node says in its have, puts it in the part's own object bucket by digest and writes the key with
digest, revision, user count, users left out and which list to follow. take-over is refused, naming why, while no list is
sealed to the bus node's current key or the loaded list does not grant the bus node its read.
Review of fix/1945-takeover-blockers: no responders on the router's record is an error, not 'no record'; an answer whose
record cannot be reached is not closed; an ask that failed to publish is taken back at the router; an error acting on an
answer is logged. Pins mesh-sdk 175a5567.
The part composed every membership with no root-free input, so telegram's verified-sender was dropped and the membership held as a shadow
difference. It now asks mesh-controller.root-free for the machines a composition needs, per pass, failing closed and said once, and wakes
on root-not-free condition-raised and condition-cleared.
mesh/check pass aea22bf793b4 on 7ddbf40715ff | unit 168 run, 479 kept | integration 178 run, 545 kept | composition passed on novox
The part reads seats, buckets, logs and streams, never a config value, and
the merge gate already judged the fallbacks; reading the controller's
predefined mirror would tie the part to the leaving controller (ADR 0547
clause 1). ParseManifestForInputs takes a fallback as it declares itself.
Issue: 1945
A manifest falling back to a predefined key (claude-code, dunst) was parsed
with no list, refused silently, and its module counted as placed nowhere, so
three memberships would lose claude-code's reach addresses and were held back.
The part now reads the list the controller mirrors (mesh-controller.predefined,
key list), follows it, and lists every manifest it cannot read in its gaps,
its pass (refused) and its log.
Issue: 1945
mesh/check checking 12f16bbebd40 on 13380e3d0e52 | novox/mesh-delivery#58 in group fix/1790-grants-create-buckets
A module's new state reached the bus only when the controller started (issue 1790, met three
times: puts, queues, mesh-vault's bus-accounts). The operator allowed one more grant in the
controller's composer on 2026-10-26 08:54, creation only: the part's process now creates each
bucket, log or stream a placed module's manifest declares and the bus lacks, with the same
configuration the controller asserts (mesh-sdk BucketStreamConfig, Log.Config,
ModuleStreamConfig), on the event that brought the manifest, never on a timer. It says asserted
and logs one line per module; a stream the bus holds is never updated or deleted, its difference
only said; a create refused is said and tried at the next event; one created at this manifest
and gone since is made again only by hand. grants_assert asks the process to do the same for one
module now. The user list, the grants and any change to a held stream stay in shadow. mesh-sdk
moves to fix/1790-grants-create-buckets, whose composer grants this, so the shadow list is
composed as the controller's.
Issue: 1790
The guard that holds back a membership losing anything held back five since 01:24: the frozen
controller's memberships still serve the delivery seat's mark-ready, which mesh-sdk d506f21
retired on purpose (ADR 0421), so every membership composed with today's seat catalogue looked
like a loss. A seat verb the catalogue defines no longer is now dropped from the comparison and
named in the pass (retired); any other loss, a module's own seat's verbs included, is still
refused. The log named only the first held membership: it now says each one, with what it would
lose, whenever the set changes, and grants_membership with neither node nor module lists them.
Issue: 1945
mesh/check pass 9132b6a296b9 on 13380e3d0e52 | unit 168 run, 473 kept | integration 178 run, 539 kept | composition passed in 36ms on novox
ADR 0547 clause 9: the vault writes the hash of each bus account it holds into bus-accounts.<user>. The grants part
watches that state (no timer), carries the hash with each shadow user in memory only, and its user-list tool says per
user whether a hash is held and how its line would differ from the loaded one (same, adds, left out for want of a
credential, loses its login); never the hash, since bcrypt salts make two hashes incomparable. Take-over names the
users with no hash.
Issue: 1945
Composed without a root-free judgement, a membership would drop a kind's verified-sender and the
operator's channel approvals would stop being honoured; any loss now stays a shadow difference,
named. A tool no longer waits on a pass's round trip. compose-now says the controller serves no
verb to write a module's grant again.
Since release 6 nobody publishes memberships, so a module placed since cannot serve its seat
or reach a new state (the operator, 2026-10-25 22:31). The part publishes each membership on
the assignments stream only when it differs from the one last published, composes from the
manifest the wanted build names, and says a refused publish and tries again at the next event.
Pins mesh-sdk 881da7f, whose composer grants mesh-grants that publish.
The grants part must compose with the controller's own composer before it can take over the
list; in shadow it proves the two agree, names every input the bus does not carry yet, and
takes no effect. It claims no seat (mesh-sdk's seat list does not name mesh-grants for the
running composer), serves module tools, and keeps running when a read or write is refused.
jschoubben