mesh/check failed: integration: meshbuildgo/cmd/mesh-build-go.TestAComposeAskIsBuiltOnceAndAnsweredOnTheBus: NOT CHECKED: the node-engine's composer c…
The test read mesh-controller/module.json beside the check, which no longer exists after the
controller's removal (issue 1126, ADR 0593 §11), so it would fail every check of the node-engine.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
ADR 0593 §7: the environment's rendering left mesh-sdk for the node-engine,
so its two integration tests (the POSIX environment sourced twice, and
the service manager reading the systemd rendering) move with it.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
ADR 0593 §7: the composition is the node-engine's, so its tests hold
what the indexer's judge tests and route-proxy's tests proved by
composing: a bundle's words per machine, a Go bundle's delivery, the
credential form in a handed plan, settings refusals, placeholder and
vault refusals, the session's files, a field set aside composed whole,
route-proxy's manifest composing for a machine, a route endpoint's
machine port in six cases and the plan's route entry end to end. Two
table tests, one subtest per item; route-proxy's manifest is captured
beside the catalogue.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
ADR 0593 §7: the composer with its refusals leaves mesh-sdk, so mesh-sdk
carries no composition rule. The catalogue functions only the
node-engine's composition reaches (Resolve, Resolution's Compose,
Declaration, DataItems, LeftOut, Rules and the rest, the settings,
placeholder and template refusals, the rendering helpers) are copied
with their tests into internal/compose/resolution; a method of a
mesh-sdk shape becomes a function taking it first. The composition
calls its own copies, and the captured catalogue its tests read lives
here now, shared by mesh-compose's tests.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
ADR 0593 §6: a composition read from composed-<node> is a record never
applied, and the engine applies only what it composes itself, so no
composition carries a signature and nothing is verified. The agent's
trusted signers, its signed-composition test and the unused signing
helper of the integration bed go, so mesh-sdk can drop SignComposed,
VerifyComposed and Composed.Signature.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
The test budget: mesh-host is over 500 unit tests, so the three tests
added for ADR 0593 §6 and §7 are paid for by folding the private
network's hub refusals, its MTU cases and its no-self-peer check into
table-driven tests, each case kept.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
ADR 0593 §6, §7, §9: the integration test runs the node agent against
the real bus under the grant the grants part composes for a node: it
publishes web's composition in composed-<node> with the digest its have
names, and answers compose-candidate for the indexer's candidate,
changing nothing. A node that cannot compose now answers unready, so
the checker counts it as no answer by the verdict and never by words.
The golden grant reads the indexer's candidates and verdicts as it
reads the builder's builds.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
ADR 0593 §6: composed-<node> is written again, by the node's engine,
each composition with its plan. The verb composition finds a published
revision by the digest the have and want name, its resources', so a plan
on the record does not hide it. The golden node grant also reads the
indexer's verdicts, which compose-candidate takes for a candidate's
manifests.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
ADR 0593 §7: a check's composition is the checker's, made from each
placed node's answer, since only a node can compose with its own sealed
values. The node composes the indexer's candidate in shadow on a copy of
its shadow's inputs, the candidate's modules laid over the indexer's
with their manifest verdicts, and answers per module composed (changed
or not), refused or held, and its own composition's verdict, within the
answer bound; it applies, writes and hands nothing. With input it also
answers the composition input, for the sandbox path.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
ADR 0593 §6: the provisioner, the assigner and the view read compositions
instead of composing, so the node's engine writes each one it makes to
its composition state: the wanted builds, every placed module at its
newest done build (so the plan exists before the want moves), each with
its provisioning plan, and a module refused alone with its refusal. A
key is written only when it differs, and kept while among the module's
five newest or named by a want. A placed module's trunk build landing
now makes a pass.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
ADR 0593 §1 and §7: compose, its bus reader and runtime reader, takein,
validate, the overlay generator, the composer's run and mesh-compose, and
the judgement of a move leave mesh-sdk for the node-engine's internal
packages, so no other module composes and a change to them rebuilds only
the node-engine. The shapes others read (the composer's request and
verdict, the overlay's names, compositions and answers) stay in mesh-sdk.
The node's grant is now a golden file of what the grants part composes,
since the composer of the bus's user list leaves mesh-sdk too.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
The bus module on the bus node runs from what its agent holds (its own composition, or the declaration kept before the
switch: every novox have read 2026-11-02 names its own composition or none, and nats names a build alone), while
composed-<node> was written by the controller, which ended (issue 1126). The follower now looks at the agent's record
of what runs whenever it changed, writes again only when the file it names moved, and trusts no composition signer.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
Every node composes its own since group A (issue 1126), so the resync that handed the vault an own secret's value
while a node applied the controller's compositions never runs, the shadow's answers read no want, and nothing follows
the heard vault key any more.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
nox now calls the seats' verbs through the console itself (mesh-catalog #593), and the controller the engine forwarded
its lines to ended (issue 1126), so the socket, its forward and the subject it asked on go. The kernel's word on a
peer moves into the filled-file socket, its one remaining reader.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
The CONTROL stream the facts, the enrolment and the overlay rekey were published into was the controller's, which ended
by its unassignment (issue 1126) and whose stream is removed after group B's delivery: a publish there would fail every
facts event before its haves are written. The facts go into the haves as they did after the report, the enrolment goes
through mesh-enrolment alone, and overlay take is refused because no seat takes a rekey now.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
The controller that signed the hand-over, search, judgement, access and move asks ended (issue 1126), so a link
believes none of them by having no signer, and the per-ask key it was told to follow goes with the lease.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
The controller's declared-packages mirror ended with the controller (issue 1126) and is deleted after group B's
delivery, so the verb no longer reads or compares it.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
The controller ended by its unassignment (issue 1126, ADR 0590), so no build is judged by the lease: the lease
witness, its contract and the direct get the witness asked it with are removed, and its tests now prove each rollback
path on the node tools' PING.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
mesh/check being carried to 38d666f22390 on 84737f4cb26d | from 14a12cc7b6f9
The controller ended by its unassignment, so a node that falls back to the
compositions in its bucket follows what nobody writes (issue 1126, A7). The
node agent now always runs its own composer: without a placement key it
composes nothing and keeps what runs, a placement it cannot watch stops the
agent and is said, and a candidate taking its placement away is refused
instead of answered as a return to the controller. The start-time placement
read, the end-when-placed watchers and the returning answer go, with their
tests and the three integration tests of the controller-composed path.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
The controller ended by its unassignment and its lease is never handed, so
the engine's lease gate kept trusting the controller's key and the bus node
kept the controller's list as a fallback nobody writes (issue 1126, A6).
The engine now trusts no controller signature, its hand-over line names the
node seat's hand-over, and the user-list follower writes only the grants
part's list: a key unreadable or deleted keeps the list loaded, and with no
key heard nothing is written. Compositions in the node's bucket name the
file's place alone. The guard no longer asks for the controller's user.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
A fall back to the old login during a rotation is now delivery.NodeHealth's Fallback (the node, the login fallen back from,
why, when), written with the node's health report, from which the watchman raises node-account-fallback; it is said no more
once the vault's key of the node moves on (blocker 7, ADR 0583 §6). mesh-host enrol's fall back to the controller's
enrolment subject says it is the path before the lease write, which the bus refuses once the lease is written. Tests: rows
in the existing rotation test; none added.
(issue 774)
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
A stand-in vault reloads a nats-server's users as the grants part's list is loaded, and the engine's own rotation code runs
against it with real test-dials and a real confirmation request: at every step at least one login authenticates; the engine
switches only once the list holds both logins and confirms in the new login's name; at rotation-done the old login is
retired and its value dropped; with the list never loaded the test-dial is refused and the engine never switches; and an
abandon after the switch brings the engine back to the old login before the new value goes (ADR 0583 §2-§6). One integration
test; mesh-host holds seven of fifty. The real vault and the real engine together are proven live on g14 first.
(issue 774, 774/S65)
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
The engine dials as enrol.<node> on the pinned certificate, calls redeem with the public halves of its keys and a proof over
them (the SDK's RedeemProof, which binds the node and the keys and never the token's secret), asks again while the holder
says to, and verifies the vault's answer against the key its token carries before it keeps anything: an answer signed by
another key, naming another signer or node, or altered is refused and nothing is kept. A signed one is kept (membership,
login, keys), then the node dials as the login it was given, reads its key of node-logins, and calls confirm; nothing is
applied until its placement names a module. When the bus does not serve the seat to the token (the controller still holds its
lease) the controller's enrolment subject is used as before. The token's shape is mesh-sdk's now: identity keeps its names as
aliases. Tests: one added, paid by merging three identity token tests into one (net two fewer).
(issue 774, 774/S64)
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
On node-logins' ready the engine fetches the new value through the vault's own hand-out (own/<node>/mesh-host/<login>, opened
with its sealing key), dials a second connection as the new login on the pinned certificate, and switches only if that
authenticates, then calls mesh-vault.node-account-confirm over the link as the new login (the vault is asked in the name of
the login the open link authenticated as, and only once that link is open). It keeps the old value until the key says the
rotation is done and drops it then, never before; an abandon, after the switch before or after the confirmation, switches
back before the new value is dropped; repeated refusals of the new login's credentials before rotation-done bring it back
to the old one, said as the finding node-account-fallback (in the journal: no route for an engine's finding to the watchman
is decided), and the same rotation is not tried again. Tests: two added, paid by merging two identity sealing tests into one;
more to be paid by deleting the identity token tests that move to mesh-sdk with the token (774/S64).
(issue 774, 774/S62, 774/S63)
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
A membership may name its Logins (ADR 0583 §1): the login in use and the password of each login held, kept beside the
identity, so a restart dials as the login in use. The engine follows its own key of node-logins as a watch on every link
and dials as the login it names when it holds its value, with the node's one inbox; with no key, or a key naming the first
login, it dials node.<n> with the membership's password as before. A change of the login in use drops the link so it is
opened again as the new one, and the vault is asked in the name of the login dialled (the subject names the caller).
Tests: one added, paid by merging the pinned-broker test with the malformed-pin test (two into one).
(issue 774, 774/S61)
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
A key that later cannot be read or is deleted is said, the key last heard stands and the list loaded stays. A key without
the flag still falls back, as before.
Tests: three rows added to the existing table test of the follower; no new test function. Built against the group's
mesh-sdk through a go.work outside the tree; go.mod is not re-pinned here.
(issue 774, 774/S31)
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
pacman still reads the controller's mirror because no engine wrote its key: the engine
now keeps each handed composition's package resources and, after a pass that handed
something new, writes mesh-host_packages.<node> only when the value differs, owed after
the growing bound when refused. The manifest declares the state so the grants part
creates it. The verb packages answers the key beside the mirror's key for the node and
their difference, and with write writes the key again from what was composed. H8's
integration test proves the write under the grant the grants part composes.
Needs mesh-sdk feat/node-packages (0ef7c0c) for DeclaredPackagesOf and the engine's read of the
mirror (go.mod pin left for the lead: the SDK commit is not pushed).
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
Issue 1585, S17: the engine decodes manifests leniently; a module whose manifest the indexer refused is held and named,
its data key stands, and every other module's items are still published. Policy, HoldsData and the certificate check no
longer parse with the judge.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
mesh/check pass e031758e4a37 on 6c1f7cc7f50f | unit 4510 run, 4259 kept, 49 skipped | integration 4589 run, 4361 kept, 51 skipped | over bound: unit, …
The builder claims a done key again as a new revision, so a build kept as done is dropped on any
write of its key. Data items that could not be worked out or written stay due and owe a pass after
the growing bound, so a first write refused before the state or grant exists is tried again
without waiting for an unrelated composition.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
The data items after a pass re-read each placed module's build over the bus (about 55 per pass on
ace, g14 and shanks); a done build never changes, so the composer keeps it. The items are now
worked out with the pass's own kept builds and modules run inside the node's own, as composed.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
After a pass that handed a new composition, the node's composer works out its modules' data
items from the inputs it composed from and writes each module's key <node>.<module> of
mesh-host_data only when it differs, deleting the keys of modules that left. Pins mesh-sdk
feat/data-items for the contract and the engine's grant. Two tool-answer tests are merged so
the unit count stays where it was.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
mesh/check being carried to 71afdf3ad234 on 6c1f7cc7f50f | from ffa63d25a066
novox's postgres stayed held after mesh-host #189: its have, written before that fix,
names no build, so the node's own composition still took it in and was refused for its
secret reader before the start could back it up again. Only that exact record leaves
the node's own; every other have naming nothing keeps main's rule. Completes #189 for a
have written before it (issue 1289).
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
mesh/check being carried to 76c7ddfc5227 on ffa63d25a066 | from a4713e2d28d7
Review round 1: a have naming no build in a phase but running is also written for a
module that runs inside the node's own (waiting for a yes), so taking it out would
drop its resources before the yes. The fp the held have now keeps already fixes
postgres (issue 1289); a test drives an interrupted backup end to end.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
On novox (2026-10-31) postgres's repeat backup was interrupted by the node-engine's
restart: its held have named no build, so the node's own composition took postgres in
and was refused for its secret reader, and nothing ran the backup again. Issue 1289
(R4c, its delivery held).
- A held have names what runs: read from the module's have before backing-up when
the agent has no running entry, as the not-composed mark does.
- A have in any phase but running that names nothing is not run inside the node's own.
- A backup interrupted by the agent's stop is no failure: the next start backs the
module up again and applies while the want asks a backup. A real failure stays
held for the operator's answer.
Quick fix: a new backup ask by hand. Thorough, chosen: the fault fixed where it lives
in the node agent, so every data module's interrupted backup resumes by itself.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01NcbgfJ9Gum47zkFKWRaovL
mesh/check failed: shanks: the check of novox/mesh-controller#487 failed: go mod download in modules/route-proxy: go: git.novox.be/novox/mesh-controll…
mesh/check being carried to da0f8f1cfdb4 on bb8383b065a1 | from 62b211bb6040
Every put under want.<node>.>, every module's take-in and every placement write
made a pass, and each pass asked the vault for the node's own secrets. The
shadow's change check moves onto the composer, gains the want (by its
fingerprint, the only part composed) and serves both loops.
On the bus node restic's manifest replaced its process measure by awake (mesh-catalog 35ff67bd). The record of restic.measure was the node's, made while restic was folded, so restic's own apply never saw it, and the guard against removing a placed module's resources refused the node's own apply whole every two minutes from 2026-10-30 19:42: nothing of the node's own applied.
Quick fix considered: forget the one record by hand (a hand act on the node; refused). Thorough fix (this): the node's own apply keeps such a record and says so, never refusing or removing it; a module's own apply owns a node record whose id names it, so it alone removes it once neither composition declares it.
mesh/check being carried to b0d6684d3731 on 91fb323ce0cf | from mesh-sdk dec3bfe7a8cb | novox/mesh-host#185 in group fix/compose-retries-transient
The verb compose has no warrant (ADR 0563 §2): Agent.Retry released a module held for a failed backup and re-applied
one already running its want. RetryFailed tries again only a failed apply not held, and refuses in words otherwise.
A hand ask no longer restarts the growing bound, and a pass less than askedWithin old is the answer, so a caller in a
loop drives no passes against the vault. A composer whose loop ended refuses at once. The retry line said try N+1.
The test's first shadow now ends before slowAfter is set, a race the race detector found under the new timing.
On 2026-10-31 ace's route-proxy said only that the vault could not be asked, and ace said nothing for five minutes
while a pass waited after the vault restarted; the retry that already existed was invisible. A refusal for a seat or
a read that did not answer now says when the node composes again ("the node composes again at HH:MM:SS (try N)"), a
retry pass says it starts, a pass that runs on says every minute what it waits on, and the node-engine's verb
compose makes a pass now and says how it went, so a person recovers without a restart.
Four providers waited for a yes on 2026-10-31 and nobody could read what waited: the have said only
"where its data is kept". The read verb composition answers it from the engine: the latest revision of the
want's build or the one asked by digest, every revision the bucket keeps, what runs and where that is known from,
the want and the have, the move's judgement and whether it waits for a yes, and with diff the resources that
differ, a received file naming its consumers. revisionNamed now reads the same revisions.
waitsForYes returned at once for a composition equal to what runs, and settleOne then found nothing to apply, so
the have kept phase waiting-yes for a move that no longer existed (ace.postgres, novox.postgres, novox.keycloak and
novox.mongodb on 2026-10-31). The have is now rewritten to running.
Quick fix: rewrite the have where the equal composition is met. Thorough fix (not here): one place that writes a
module's have from the settled state after every settle, so no early return can leave a stale phase.
The review of d5e8458 found that mesh-wireguard, provided by the mesh and never wanted at a fingerprint, kept the kept
declaration read on every node for ever, against ADR 0550 §2 once the lease is written. A selfcompose row shows the
node's own composes it from delivery.ProvidedManifest with nothing running, so the kept read holds nothing of it.
Quick fix: name mesh-wireguard in allHave. Thorough fix: allHave counts every module delivery.ProvidedByMesh says the
mesh provides as covered. Chose thorough: one list of provided modules, mesh-sdk's.
mesh/check checking 33131dcbfe77 on 2ae7c53376e8 | novox/mesh-host#181 in group fix/build-not-done-holds-one-module
At 19:30 on 2026-10-30 node-tools' want moved to a build not yet done; once it landed, ace, g14 and shanks stayed
refused until some other input moved (g14 and shanks at 19:40, ace after a restart), since the composer watched no
build.
Quick fix: compose again on a timer while anything is held. Thorough fix: the composer watches the builder's builds
(within the node's compose reads, NodeComposeReads) and makes a pass when a done build of a module the node wants, at
its want's or the trunk's build, lands; nothing else moves it. With mesh-sdk 9685990a (pinned here) a running module
whose build is not done is held, keeping what runs, so the pass that waited composes it as soon as it lands. Chose
thorough: event-driven, no poll.
mesh/check checking 4055e0094b48 on ee71ba4dea81 | novox/mesh-host#180 in group fix/one-bad-item-holds-one-module
At 19:13 on 2026-10-30 power's bar item (mesh-catalog ca8d6f33) made frombus.Compose refuse the whole node, and the
composer marked every module not composed (32 of 81 failed on shanks). The composer already holds what Compose names
held (NotComposedEach, issue 1126); the SDK now names a refused manifest's module held instead of refusing the node.
Quick fix: none in mesh-host; thorough fix is the SDK's input (one rule for Compose, Answer and PlansHeld). The test
replays the captured power manifest and fails on the old pin with the live words.
jschoubben
mesh-tools