Prove a mesh credential becomes a login, against a real database

The mesh generates a password, seals it to the machine that must accept
it, and discards the plaintext — so it cannot tell PostgreSQL to start
accepting it. Something on that machine reads what the host wrote and
makes it true. Everything up to that step is proven elsewhere; this is
where a password either becomes a login or does not.

A scenario with one machine and a database, and six assertions: the
password works, running again reaches the same state and says nothing,
rotation makes the new one work and the old one stop, a departed consumer
loses its login, a role nobody here made is left alone, and a manifest
naming a credential that was never written is refused rather than
creating a login with no password.

Each was confirmed to fail — and only it to fail — with the behaviour
removed from the provisioner: only-creates breaks rotation, no-revoke
breaks revocation, revoking everything breaks the bystander role, and
ignoring a missing credential breaks the refusal.

Two faults in the test itself, both worth recording:

- it checked logins from inside the database's own container over
  127.0.0.1, which PostgreSQL's default pg_hba trusts. No password was
  ever verified. Demonstrated directly: over loopback a deliberately
  wrong password still returns a row. Only the rotation assertion
  noticed, because it is the one that requires a password to STOP
  working — which is an argument for writing that assertion every time.
- the fix then read .NetworkSettings.IPAddress, which docker 29 no
  longer populates. It templates to empty, psql falls back to a unix
  socket that is not there, and every login looks impossible rather than
  misconfigured.
This commit is contained in:
2026-08-30 01:29:46 +02:00
parent c79b83c1bc
commit e89379fef8
3 changed files with 327 additions and 0 deletions
+47
View File
@@ -0,0 +1,47 @@
# Provisioners
The half that makes a credential real.
The mesh generates a password, seals it to the machine that must accept it, and never holds the
value — so it cannot tell PostgreSQL, or MinIO, or a broker, to start accepting it. Something on
that machine reads what arrived and makes it true. That something is a provisioner, and it belongs
to the module that ships the software, not to the mesh.
**What the mesh owns is the contract.** A provider module declares:
```json
{
"provides": [{"name": "database", "scope": "mesh"}],
"receives": {"database": "/var/lib/postgres/grants/mesh.json"},
"grants": {"database": "/var/lib/postgres/grants"}
}
```
and is then given, by the host, from an ordinary declaration:
| | |
|---|---|
| `mesh.json` | every consumer, what it asked for, and where its credential is |
| `<node>.secret` | one consumer's password, alone in the file, sealed in transit and written in plain by the host |
Two files rather than one because the mesh discarded the plaintext and cannot compose a document
containing it. The consequence is a good one: the readable half stays readable, and the secret
half changes only when the secret does.
**A provisioner reconciles; it is not told what changed.** It runs after every declaration and
must reach the same state from wherever it starts. That means, in order:
1. every consumer in the manifest has what it asked for, with the password it was given — set
every time, not only on creation, or a rotation reports success and changes nothing
2. **everything this provisioner made that is no longer asked for is removed.** A consumer that
goes away otherwise leaves a working login behind for ever, and nothing says so
Step 2 is the half usually missing, and it is the same rule the host follows about removing what
it declared and no longer declares.
The reference implementation lives in `mesh-control/examples/postgres-provisioner`, because that
is where the contract is defined and where the language is already set up to read it. The lab's
job is the other half: raising a real PostgreSQL and proving that what the mesh delivered becomes
a login that works, a rotation that takes effect, and a revocation that bites.
Set `MESH_LAB_PROVISIONER` to a built one to run those.