Design 47 H2: H-A-453, mesh-catalog's review round 1 answers

This commit is contained in:
2026-11-22 02:22:57 +01:00
parent 9553ce0e83
commit 93039639e5
@@ -671,3 +671,16 @@ The lead's one-line answers to the questions H2's develop and review raise (impl
seatlisttest, the one test seat list every repository's tests share (P3), so the refresh is a mesh-sdk commit: seatlisttest
gains the mesh-recovery seat and every other definition the group's heads hold that it lacks, resolved as the live list
is; no captured list of the validator's own. P3.
- **H-A-453 (mesh-catalog's review round 1, 02:52)** (1) P2 (§781's converged timeout) is not H2's: H-A-350 DMC-12 gave
the converged verb, its timeout and the allow to the packet filter group, merged on 21 Nov; the row is closed, no code.
(2) A package outside every artifact's `from` (the forge module's internal/seatgit whole test, which needs the Node build
seat) declares its need at the module's level: the manifest's top-level `check-needs` (a list of seat names, the same
form as an artifact's), read by the Go build module for the packages no artifact's `from` holds; gitea declares
`check-needs: ["node-build-node"]`; mesh-sdk's `catalogue.Manifest` gains the field (one line). (3) A whole criterion is
proven at its level: GT1 (§809), GT2 and SC1 (§810), RG3 (§813 (8)) and C4 (§808 "the forge holds one token after") each
become a step of their module's existing whole test, no new top-level function; P1 (§813 (4)) stays a unit test, since
no whole packet-filter test exists (noted for H2b). (4) §819 reads as the test-budget instruction has it: a module's
count never rises in a change, and a module over budget shrinks with every change that touches its tests; a module
whose count stands where it was is accepted this milestone (the fold of nine modules' tests would cost more than the
rule protects tonight: rules-are-weighed, said here). The fills gitea's caps rest on are written in a commit (H-A-437),
and tweetnacl is declared where test/fakebus.ts imports it. P3, rules-are-weighed.