assigner: a backup ask only for a failed backup (A-453, A-453a) #237

Merged
mesh-tools merged 3 commits from fix/47-G-backup-ask-only-for-failed-backup into main 2026-11-16 23:51:25 +00:00
Member

Builds design 47 G's lead answers A-453 and A-453a (ADR 0539 §16, §541). Live: about forty false "The backup of ... failed" asks at 2026-11-17 00:32 for modules held only for entry-missing.

  • passer.backups asks only for a held have with no wait.
  • staleAsk withdraws a backup ask when its have runs, is removed, or is not held at another fingerprint; a held have and a have mid-move keep it.
  • Tests: rows in existing unit tests; the backup integration test now writes what the node-engine writes (held at the running build, backing-up at the move's).
  • Ordering edge: the node-engine's half (holds carry their wait, mesh-host fix/47-G-hold-carries-its-wait) lands first; until then this changes nothing live.
  • Known: TestAProposalIsAnsweredApprovedAndWritten fails on main too.

Reviewed-by: mesh-code-reviewer@shanks at 482a618d1e (3 rounds)

Builds design 47 G's lead answers A-453 and A-453a (ADR 0539 §16, §541). Live: about forty false "The backup of ... failed" asks at 2026-11-17 00:32 for modules held only for entry-missing. - passer.backups asks only for a held have with no wait. - staleAsk withdraws a backup ask when its have runs, is removed, or is not held at another fingerprint; a held have and a have mid-move keep it. - Tests: rows in existing unit tests; the backup integration test now writes what the node-engine writes (held at the running build, backing-up at the move's). - Ordering edge: the node-engine's half (holds carry their wait, mesh-host fix/47-G-hold-carries-its-wait) lands first; until then this changes nothing live. - Known: TestAProposalIsAnsweredApprovedAndWritten fails on main too. Reviewed-by: mesh-code-reviewer@shanks at 482a618d1e378cb73a080d8724601930fc26b8e5 (3 rounds)
mesh-tools added 3 commits 2026-11-16 23:51:19 +00:00
A held have that carries a wait is a hold of the composition, not a failed backup; a backup ask whose have now carries a wait or is no longer held is withdrawn with its condition.

Builds: design 47 G A-453, ADR 0539 §16, §541
Builds: design 47 G A-453, A-453a, ADR 0539 §16
Builds: design 47 G A-453, A-453a, ADR 0539 §16
mesh-tools merged commit 44bdbbcbed into main 2026-11-16 23:51:25 +00:00
mesh-tools deleted branch fix/47-G-backup-ask-only-for-failed-backup 2026-11-16 23:51:26 +00:00
Author
Member

{
"records": [
{
"instance": "record/main_992_5ae6ed5f/a591d9407576f71b",
"sequence": 9607,
"bytes": 1830,
"of-bytes": 262144,
"waits": "its difference is not known yet",
"record": {
"milestone": "main.992",
"heads": {
"novox/mesh-delivery@237": "44bdbbcbedd3d14ce05f2e072a7d795d8375484b"
},
"opened": "2026-11-17T07:55:56.646782769Z",
"form": 1,
"group": {
"group": "",
"members": [
"novox/mesh-catalog@697",
"novox/mesh-delivery@238",
"novox/mesh-host@233"
],
"pulls": [
{
"repository": "novox/mesh-delivery",
"number": 237,
"head": "44bdbbcbedd3d14ce05f2e072a7d795d8375484b",
"state": "merged",
"commit": "44bdbbcbedd3d14ce05f2e072a7d795d8375484b"
}
]
},
"entries": {
"mesh-delivery-assigner|src2:c723d3d756e23a1d76ff0e1ea6c2a64632217d0e488933db4769df392f369dfd|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-assigner|src2:c723d3d756e23a1d76ff0e1ea6c2a64632217d0e488933db4769df392f369dfd|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-assigner",
"fingerprint": "src2:c723d3d756e23a1d76ff0e1ea6c2a64632217d0e488933db4769df392f369dfd"
},
"mesh-delivery-gate|src2:8dec18c3c71e1766b5c8700b79e18281b36d3589a393e22002b8ee57b0f42c79|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-gate|src2:8dec18c3c71e1766b5c8700b79e18281b36d3589a393e22002b8ee57b0f42c79|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-gate",
"fingerprint": "src2:8dec18c3c71e1766b5c8700b79e18281b36d3589a393e22002b8ee57b0f42c79"
},
"mesh-host|src2:57054aefce091d97cb871a00140b27c0ba02b4dbf0a7682b39db6daab0b6b6e9|": {
"key": "mesh-host|src2:57054aefce091d97cb871a00140b27c0ba02b4dbf0a7682b39db6daab0b6b6e9|",
"module": "mesh-host",
"fingerprint": "src2:57054aefce091d97cb871a00140b27c0ba02b4dbf0a7682b39db6daab0b6b6e9"
}
},
"outcomes": {
"|||take-in": {
"key": "|||take-in",
"module": "",
"step": "take-in",
"outcome": "taken-in",
"why": "the wait names indexer build src2:e907f553, which cannot run before this take-in (its own delivery needs it); the indexer program running on novox since 08:51 is pack41, built from mesh-delivery main eed0833a, mesh-catalog 9ade421e and mesh-contracts ba11b5e9. The operator approved moving these merges (02:14). lead-47@shanks",
"at": "2026-11-17T07:55:56.646086328Z"
}
}
}
}
]
}

<!-- mesh-delivery:view --> { "records": [ { "instance": "record/main_992_5ae6ed5f/a591d9407576f71b", "sequence": 9607, "bytes": 1830, "of-bytes": 262144, "waits": "its difference is not known yet", "record": { "milestone": "main.992", "heads": { "novox/mesh-delivery@237": "44bdbbcbedd3d14ce05f2e072a7d795d8375484b" }, "opened": "2026-11-17T07:55:56.646782769Z", "form": 1, "group": { "group": "", "members": [ "novox/mesh-catalog@697", "novox/mesh-delivery@238", "novox/mesh-host@233" ], "pulls": [ { "repository": "novox/mesh-delivery", "number": 237, "head": "44bdbbcbedd3d14ce05f2e072a7d795d8375484b", "state": "merged", "commit": "44bdbbcbedd3d14ce05f2e072a7d795d8375484b" } ] }, "entries": { "mesh-delivery-assigner|src2:c723d3d756e23a1d76ff0e1ea6c2a64632217d0e488933db4769df392f369dfd|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-assigner|src2:c723d3d756e23a1d76ff0e1ea6c2a64632217d0e488933db4769df392f369dfd|", "module": "mesh-delivery-assigner", "fingerprint": "src2:c723d3d756e23a1d76ff0e1ea6c2a64632217d0e488933db4769df392f369dfd" }, "mesh-delivery-gate|src2:8dec18c3c71e1766b5c8700b79e18281b36d3589a393e22002b8ee57b0f42c79|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-gate|src2:8dec18c3c71e1766b5c8700b79e18281b36d3589a393e22002b8ee57b0f42c79|", "module": "mesh-delivery-gate", "fingerprint": "src2:8dec18c3c71e1766b5c8700b79e18281b36d3589a393e22002b8ee57b0f42c79" }, "mesh-host|src2:57054aefce091d97cb871a00140b27c0ba02b4dbf0a7682b39db6daab0b6b6e9|": { "key": "mesh-host|src2:57054aefce091d97cb871a00140b27c0ba02b4dbf0a7682b39db6daab0b6b6e9|", "module": "mesh-host", "fingerprint": "src2:57054aefce091d97cb871a00140b27c0ba02b4dbf0a7682b39db6daab0b6b6e9" } }, "outcomes": { "|||take-in": { "key": "|||take-in", "module": "", "step": "take-in", "outcome": "taken-in", "why": "the wait names indexer build src2:e907f553, which cannot run before this take-in (its own delivery needs it); the indexer program running on novox since 08:51 is pack41, built from mesh-delivery main eed0833a, mesh-catalog 9ade421e and mesh-contracts ba11b5e9. The operator approved moving these merges (02:14). lead-47@shanks", "at": "2026-11-17T07:55:56.646086328Z" } } } } ] } <!-- mesh-act:view.record/main_992_5ae6ed5f/a591d9407576f71b.novox/mesh-delivery#237@1794902162860592376.f57c75a8 -->
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Reviewers
No labels
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: novox/mesh-delivery#237