assigner: a composition step never passes on a machine it did not judge (A-467) #242

Merged
mesh-tools merged 1 commits from fix/47-G-composition-judges into main 2026-11-17 09:47:26 +00:00
Member

Design 47 G, the lead's answer A-467 (hq G-22-lead-answers-2.md).

  • verdictOf: the composer's not judged ends that machine could not run, naming why (was a warning), so a step that judged nothing never passes.
  • seats(): while the step's catalog revision names no definitions (A-234's stand-in), the assigner reads the trunk seat list through mesh-catalog's seat-definitions (one list call, then each seat at its digest, cached); a list that cannot be read or names no seat ends the step could not run before any ask.

Live: main.992.mesh-delivery-gate and -pipeline passed at 10:24-10:25 with 'novox was not judged: the composer was handed no seat list'; revision 449 carries no definitions. Met three times (main.963, main.984, main.992).

Quick vs thorough: thorough (the kind: a pass that judged nothing, now impossible; seats always handed). Follow-up A-467a: a step whose every machine is away (reviewer's question).

Tests: vet, vet -tags integration, go test ./... pass; each change taken out fails its test (reviewer). TestAProposalIsAnsweredApprovedAndWritten fails at main too. No manifest change (seat-definitions already invoked).

Reviewed-by: mesh-code-reviewer for lead-47@shanks at db62653472 (round 1)

Design 47 G, the lead's answer A-467 (hq G-22-lead-answers-2.md). - verdictOf: the composer's not judged ends that machine could not run, naming why (was a warning), so a step that judged nothing never passes. - seats(): while the step's catalog revision names no definitions (A-234's stand-in), the assigner reads the trunk seat list through mesh-catalog's seat-definitions (one list call, then each seat at its digest, cached); a list that cannot be read or names no seat ends the step could not run before any ask. Live: main.992.mesh-delivery-gate and -pipeline passed at 10:24-10:25 with 'novox was not judged: the composer was handed no seat list'; revision 449 carries no definitions. Met three times (main.963, main.984, main.992). Quick vs thorough: thorough (the kind: a pass that judged nothing, now impossible; seats always handed). Follow-up A-467a: a step whose every machine is away (reviewer's question). Tests: vet, vet -tags integration, go test ./... pass; each change taken out fails its test (reviewer). TestAProposalIsAnsweredApprovedAndWritten fails at main too. No manifest change (seat-definitions already invoked). Reviewed-by: mesh-code-reviewer for lead-47@shanks at db62653472e71c16ad40a443573a86c55345e3b2 (round 1)
mesh-tools added 1 commit 2026-11-17 09:47:18 +00:00
A machine the composer says `not judged` ends the step could not run, naming why (was a warning). A revision that names no seat
definition (A-234's stand-in) hands the composer every definition of the trunk seat list, read through mesh-catalog's
seat-definitions; a list or definition not read ends the step could not run, naming it (was an empty list, no error). The
integration bed makes the inputs object store, which a request carrying the seat list needs.

Builds: design 47 G A-467, A-234, A-252, A-261
mesh-tools merged commit 2406bb4000 into main 2026-11-17 09:47:26 +00:00
mesh-tools deleted branch fix/47-G-composition-judges 2026-11-17 09:47:26 +00:00
Author
Member

{
"records": [
{
"instance": "record/main_1004_51af09b8/cf08ec6cdbe0f452",
"sequence": 9804,
"bytes": 5770,
"of-bytes": 262144,
"waits": "its difference is not known yet",
"record": {
"milestone": "main.1004",
"heads": {
"novox/mesh-delivery@242": "2406bb4000065820ede81580cc472366fa6cfe2f"
},
"opened": "2026-11-17T13:19:54.655089068Z",
"form": 1,
"group": {
"group": "",
"members": [
"novox/mesh-catalog@698",
"novox/mesh-delivery@244",
"novox/mesh-host@235"
],
"pulls": [
{
"repository": "novox/mesh-delivery",
"number": 242,
"head": "2406bb4000065820ede81580cc472366fa6cfe2f",
"state": "merged",
"commit": "2406bb4000065820ede81580cc472366fa6cfe2f"
}
]
},
"entries": {
"artifact-store-tools|src2:ef84e753a0ff0e51be6ab3de3a3e79fe3c98173496c4ce927bdc1e436ee6346c|": {
"key": "artifact-store-tools|src2:ef84e753a0ff0e51be6ab3de3a3e79fe3c98173496c4ce927bdc1e436ee6346c|",
"module": "artifact-store-tools",
"fingerprint": "src2:ef84e753a0ff0e51be6ab3de3a3e79fe3c98173496c4ce927bdc1e436ee6346c"
},
"mesh-build-go|src2:eeb00d135f0163a5cd5dda5d08175aea03a8a66d87ab909f2a4553253e35270a|": {
"key": "mesh-build-go|src2:eeb00d135f0163a5cd5dda5d08175aea03a8a66d87ab909f2a4553253e35270a|",
"module": "mesh-build-go",
"fingerprint": "src2:eeb00d135f0163a5cd5dda5d08175aea03a8a66d87ab909f2a4553253e35270a"
},
"mesh-conditions|src2:6f8daed461f270ef6ddbe7f10175aae5f9909110b1cd0090f025895cdaa1a026|": {
"key": "mesh-conditions|src2:6f8daed461f270ef6ddbe7f10175aae5f9909110b1cd0090f025895cdaa1a026|",
"module": "mesh-conditions",
"fingerprint": "src2:6f8daed461f270ef6ddbe7f10175aae5f9909110b1cd0090f025895cdaa1a026"
},
"mesh-config|src2:229acf6934c50ce2691909516c36c9a2c277c1e9001481be6cf5ab009723f9cc|": {
"key": "mesh-config|src2:229acf6934c50ce2691909516c36c9a2c277c1e9001481be6cf5ab009723f9cc|",
"module": "mesh-config",
"fingerprint": "src2:229acf6934c50ce2691909516c36c9a2c277c1e9001481be6cf5ab009723f9cc"
},
"mesh-delivery-assigner|src2:a2a1ad190a64aac37e172eefebf53ca17d0cd60702e14a09a0c42fe8790cee8e|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-assigner|src2:a2a1ad190a64aac37e172eefebf53ca17d0cd60702e14a09a0c42fe8790cee8e|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-assigner",
"fingerprint": "src2:a2a1ad190a64aac37e172eefebf53ca17d0cd60702e14a09a0c42fe8790cee8e"
},
"mesh-delivery-builder|src2:f03e63c2ee3f3576d08c2282a7abb3efa0a4e320df745d3566755c8110d3cbe6|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-builder|src2:f03e63c2ee3f3576d08c2282a7abb3efa0a4e320df745d3566755c8110d3cbe6|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-builder",
"fingerprint": "src2:f03e63c2ee3f3576d08c2282a7abb3efa0a4e320df745d3566755c8110d3cbe6"
},
"mesh-delivery-checker|src2:7916b9b70c8cb290d1aef06ce1274595e97309c76dfbbbd3c92cc636b820c849|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-checker|src2:7916b9b70c8cb290d1aef06ce1274595e97309c76dfbbbd3c92cc636b820c849|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-checker",
"fingerprint": "src2:7916b9b70c8cb290d1aef06ce1274595e97309c76dfbbbd3c92cc636b820c849"
},
"mesh-delivery-gate|src2:23cb0641b8ac9f3bdedb492ab1dab9956bce1f23992b3d004e0b88272702da96|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-gate|src2:23cb0641b8ac9f3bdedb492ab1dab9956bce1f23992b3d004e0b88272702da96|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-gate",
"fingerprint": "src2:23cb0641b8ac9f3bdedb492ab1dab9956bce1f23992b3d004e0b88272702da96"
},
"mesh-delivery-pipeline|src2:42dc46e4605b9f1fdcfb1d4e5eb43eec7d02e5b4ee20f5a206b633ff549fd957|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-pipeline|src2:42dc46e4605b9f1fdcfb1d4e5eb43eec7d02e5b4ee20f5a206b633ff549fd957|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-pipeline",
"fingerprint": "src2:42dc46e4605b9f1fdcfb1d4e5eb43eec7d02e5b4ee20f5a206b633ff549fd957"
},
"mesh-delivery-sdk|src2:ef81c903e9692ae12cb36d8f2f53e19c45a9ee7356df0b340f7545a835ac1e7e|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-sdk|src2:ef81c903e9692ae12cb36d8f2f53e19c45a9ee7356df0b340f7545a835ac1e7e|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-sdk",
"fingerprint": "src2:ef81c903e9692ae12cb36d8f2f53e19c45a9ee7356df0b340f7545a835ac1e7e"
},
"mesh-delivery-teller|src2:f8cf8284b0c7222ce85f68a959dda992a0e1983f220a0a176cdcaa28103f6bf1|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-teller|src2:f8cf8284b0c7222ce85f68a959dda992a0e1983f220a0a176cdcaa28103f6bf1|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-teller",
"fingerprint": "src2:f8cf8284b0c7222ce85f68a959dda992a0e1983f220a0a176cdcaa28103f6bf1"
},
"mesh-delivery-view|src2:7b672a972b4c4dfa95a8ce703d1a1cba7f1d8585009b654a04154a1465b253d2|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-view|src2:7b672a972b4c4dfa95a8ce703d1a1cba7f1d8585009b654a04154a1465b253d2|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-view",
"fingerprint": "src2:7b672a972b4c4dfa95a8ce703d1a1cba7f1d8585009b654a04154a1465b253d2"
},
"mesh-delivery-watchman|src2:07a12bf5c014d85916c882f881ee476cc75479700aaf83412d4f07fed228ddb2|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-watchman|src2:07a12bf5c014d85916c882f881ee476cc75479700aaf83412d4f07fed228ddb2|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-watchman",
"fingerprint": "src2:07a12bf5c014d85916c882f881ee476cc75479700aaf83412d4f07fed228ddb2"
},
"mesh-grants|src2:a9eb09892c5a460239c5ee0ba8d8579bebca68b7c62e236f9f038e4a511d93b3|": {
"key": "mesh-grants|src2:a9eb09892c5a460239c5ee0ba8d8579bebca68b7c62e236f9f038e4a511d93b3|",
"module": "mesh-grants",
"fingerprint": "src2:a9eb09892c5a460239c5ee0ba8d8579bebca68b7c62e236f9f038e4a511d93b3"
},
"mesh-host|src2:d371f9696729a20a2d5846f5203f2b9b4cbab50a88a46988bed6e333d6e85d6d|": {
"key": "mesh-host|src2:d371f9696729a20a2d5846f5203f2b9b4cbab50a88a46988bed6e333d6e85d6d|",
"module": "mesh-host",
"fingerprint": "src2:d371f9696729a20a2d5846f5203f2b9b4cbab50a88a46988bed6e333d6e85d6d"
},
"mesh-provisioner|src2:013bf2ad1ff861a9b4434385467735dd86b6ca76b253f4fbe791a35c742efcbe|": {
"key": "mesh-provisioner|src2:013bf2ad1ff861a9b4434385467735dd86b6ca76b253f4fbe791a35c742efcbe|",
"module": "mesh-provisioner",
"fingerprint": "src2:013bf2ad1ff861a9b4434385467735dd86b6ca76b253f4fbe791a35c742efcbe"
}
},
"outcomes": {
"|||take-in": {
"key": "|||take-in",
"module": "",
"step": "take-in",
"outcome": "taken-in",
"why": "lead-47@shanks: validation try 10 accepted the revision at 14:17; it waits for indexer build c07c2499, whose code (main 4b75791d) runs on novox since 13:27, placed by hand (pack45) under its old fingerprint e34efaac from the hand drop-in, so the named build can never be seen to run",
"at": "2026-11-17T13:19:54.654461887Z"
}
}
}
}
]
}

<!-- mesh-delivery:view --> { "records": [ { "instance": "record/main_1004_51af09b8/cf08ec6cdbe0f452", "sequence": 9804, "bytes": 5770, "of-bytes": 262144, "waits": "its difference is not known yet", "record": { "milestone": "main.1004", "heads": { "novox/mesh-delivery@242": "2406bb4000065820ede81580cc472366fa6cfe2f" }, "opened": "2026-11-17T13:19:54.655089068Z", "form": 1, "group": { "group": "", "members": [ "novox/mesh-catalog@698", "novox/mesh-delivery@244", "novox/mesh-host@235" ], "pulls": [ { "repository": "novox/mesh-delivery", "number": 242, "head": "2406bb4000065820ede81580cc472366fa6cfe2f", "state": "merged", "commit": "2406bb4000065820ede81580cc472366fa6cfe2f" } ] }, "entries": { "artifact-store-tools|src2:ef84e753a0ff0e51be6ab3de3a3e79fe3c98173496c4ce927bdc1e436ee6346c|": { "key": "artifact-store-tools|src2:ef84e753a0ff0e51be6ab3de3a3e79fe3c98173496c4ce927bdc1e436ee6346c|", "module": "artifact-store-tools", "fingerprint": "src2:ef84e753a0ff0e51be6ab3de3a3e79fe3c98173496c4ce927bdc1e436ee6346c" }, "mesh-build-go|src2:eeb00d135f0163a5cd5dda5d08175aea03a8a66d87ab909f2a4553253e35270a|": { "key": "mesh-build-go|src2:eeb00d135f0163a5cd5dda5d08175aea03a8a66d87ab909f2a4553253e35270a|", "module": "mesh-build-go", "fingerprint": "src2:eeb00d135f0163a5cd5dda5d08175aea03a8a66d87ab909f2a4553253e35270a" }, "mesh-conditions|src2:6f8daed461f270ef6ddbe7f10175aae5f9909110b1cd0090f025895cdaa1a026|": { "key": "mesh-conditions|src2:6f8daed461f270ef6ddbe7f10175aae5f9909110b1cd0090f025895cdaa1a026|", "module": "mesh-conditions", "fingerprint": "src2:6f8daed461f270ef6ddbe7f10175aae5f9909110b1cd0090f025895cdaa1a026" }, "mesh-config|src2:229acf6934c50ce2691909516c36c9a2c277c1e9001481be6cf5ab009723f9cc|": { "key": "mesh-config|src2:229acf6934c50ce2691909516c36c9a2c277c1e9001481be6cf5ab009723f9cc|", "module": "mesh-config", "fingerprint": "src2:229acf6934c50ce2691909516c36c9a2c277c1e9001481be6cf5ab009723f9cc" }, "mesh-delivery-assigner|src2:a2a1ad190a64aac37e172eefebf53ca17d0cd60702e14a09a0c42fe8790cee8e|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-assigner|src2:a2a1ad190a64aac37e172eefebf53ca17d0cd60702e14a09a0c42fe8790cee8e|", "module": "mesh-delivery-assigner", "fingerprint": "src2:a2a1ad190a64aac37e172eefebf53ca17d0cd60702e14a09a0c42fe8790cee8e" }, "mesh-delivery-builder|src2:f03e63c2ee3f3576d08c2282a7abb3efa0a4e320df745d3566755c8110d3cbe6|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-builder|src2:f03e63c2ee3f3576d08c2282a7abb3efa0a4e320df745d3566755c8110d3cbe6|", "module": "mesh-delivery-builder", "fingerprint": "src2:f03e63c2ee3f3576d08c2282a7abb3efa0a4e320df745d3566755c8110d3cbe6" }, "mesh-delivery-checker|src2:7916b9b70c8cb290d1aef06ce1274595e97309c76dfbbbd3c92cc636b820c849|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-checker|src2:7916b9b70c8cb290d1aef06ce1274595e97309c76dfbbbd3c92cc636b820c849|", "module": "mesh-delivery-checker", "fingerprint": "src2:7916b9b70c8cb290d1aef06ce1274595e97309c76dfbbbd3c92cc636b820c849" }, "mesh-delivery-gate|src2:23cb0641b8ac9f3bdedb492ab1dab9956bce1f23992b3d004e0b88272702da96|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-gate|src2:23cb0641b8ac9f3bdedb492ab1dab9956bce1f23992b3d004e0b88272702da96|", "module": "mesh-delivery-gate", "fingerprint": "src2:23cb0641b8ac9f3bdedb492ab1dab9956bce1f23992b3d004e0b88272702da96" }, "mesh-delivery-pipeline|src2:42dc46e4605b9f1fdcfb1d4e5eb43eec7d02e5b4ee20f5a206b633ff549fd957|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-pipeline|src2:42dc46e4605b9f1fdcfb1d4e5eb43eec7d02e5b4ee20f5a206b633ff549fd957|", "module": "mesh-delivery-pipeline", "fingerprint": "src2:42dc46e4605b9f1fdcfb1d4e5eb43eec7d02e5b4ee20f5a206b633ff549fd957" }, "mesh-delivery-sdk|src2:ef81c903e9692ae12cb36d8f2f53e19c45a9ee7356df0b340f7545a835ac1e7e|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-sdk|src2:ef81c903e9692ae12cb36d8f2f53e19c45a9ee7356df0b340f7545a835ac1e7e|", "module": "mesh-delivery-sdk", "fingerprint": "src2:ef81c903e9692ae12cb36d8f2f53e19c45a9ee7356df0b340f7545a835ac1e7e" }, "mesh-delivery-teller|src2:f8cf8284b0c7222ce85f68a959dda992a0e1983f220a0a176cdcaa28103f6bf1|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-teller|src2:f8cf8284b0c7222ce85f68a959dda992a0e1983f220a0a176cdcaa28103f6bf1|", "module": "mesh-delivery-teller", "fingerprint": "src2:f8cf8284b0c7222ce85f68a959dda992a0e1983f220a0a176cdcaa28103f6bf1" }, "mesh-delivery-view|src2:7b672a972b4c4dfa95a8ce703d1a1cba7f1d8585009b654a04154a1465b253d2|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-view|src2:7b672a972b4c4dfa95a8ce703d1a1cba7f1d8585009b654a04154a1465b253d2|", "module": "mesh-delivery-view", "fingerprint": "src2:7b672a972b4c4dfa95a8ce703d1a1cba7f1d8585009b654a04154a1465b253d2" }, "mesh-delivery-watchman|src2:07a12bf5c014d85916c882f881ee476cc75479700aaf83412d4f07fed228ddb2|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-watchman|src2:07a12bf5c014d85916c882f881ee476cc75479700aaf83412d4f07fed228ddb2|", "module": "mesh-delivery-watchman", "fingerprint": "src2:07a12bf5c014d85916c882f881ee476cc75479700aaf83412d4f07fed228ddb2" }, "mesh-grants|src2:a9eb09892c5a460239c5ee0ba8d8579bebca68b7c62e236f9f038e4a511d93b3|": { "key": "mesh-grants|src2:a9eb09892c5a460239c5ee0ba8d8579bebca68b7c62e236f9f038e4a511d93b3|", "module": "mesh-grants", "fingerprint": "src2:a9eb09892c5a460239c5ee0ba8d8579bebca68b7c62e236f9f038e4a511d93b3" }, "mesh-host|src2:d371f9696729a20a2d5846f5203f2b9b4cbab50a88a46988bed6e333d6e85d6d|": { "key": "mesh-host|src2:d371f9696729a20a2d5846f5203f2b9b4cbab50a88a46988bed6e333d6e85d6d|", "module": "mesh-host", "fingerprint": "src2:d371f9696729a20a2d5846f5203f2b9b4cbab50a88a46988bed6e333d6e85d6d" }, "mesh-provisioner|src2:013bf2ad1ff861a9b4434385467735dd86b6ca76b253f4fbe791a35c742efcbe|": { "key": "mesh-provisioner|src2:013bf2ad1ff861a9b4434385467735dd86b6ca76b253f4fbe791a35c742efcbe|", "module": "mesh-provisioner", "fingerprint": "src2:013bf2ad1ff861a9b4434385467735dd86b6ca76b253f4fbe791a35c742efcbe" } }, "outcomes": { "|||take-in": { "key": "|||take-in", "module": "", "step": "take-in", "outcome": "taken-in", "why": "lead-47@shanks: validation try 10 accepted the revision at 14:17; it waits for indexer build c07c2499, whose code (main 4b75791d) runs on novox since 13:27, placed by hand (pack45) under its old fingerprint e34efaac from the hand drop-in, so the named build can never be seen to run", "at": "2026-11-17T13:19:54.654461887Z" } } } } ] } <!-- mesh-act:view.record/main_1004_51af09b8/cf08ec6cdbe0f452.novox/mesh-delivery#242@1794921600307537498.51059347 -->
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Reviewers
No labels
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: novox/mesh-delivery#242