Node-engine asks a missing trunk build again on a backoff or a catalog-revision (A-487a) #238

Merged
mesh-tools merged 4 commits from fix/trunk-ask-backoff into main 2026-11-19 10:49:10 +00:00
Member

The node-engine asked the catalog for a trunk build it had none of at every composition pass, which added to the catalog's load while it was choked.

  • A trunk build the catalog gave none of is asked again on a backoff, or at once when mesh-catalog.catalog-revision is heard; never at every pass (A-487a).
  • A refused catalog-revision subscription is said once and tried again; it never refuses the watch.
  • The manifest consumes mesh-catalog.catalog-revision; one test, a subtest of an existing test.

Lead answer: hq 03-DESIGN/01-to-be/47-milestones/ A-487a (hq #717). Hears the event the catalog publishes from mesh-delivery fix/catalog-answers-from-memory; without it the backoff alone holds.

Manifest validator (indexer judge, run locally): mesh-host accepted alone; on the shelf it adds no problem against main (what it still refuses, the seats mesh-grants and mesh-recovery, it refuses on main the same way, because the validator's seat list lacks them).

Known failure on main, not this change: TestTheNodeComposesItsWantsFromTheBus under -race.

Reviewed-by: review-487@shanks at 85d1707e82

https://claude.ai/code/session_01JG73KHUnBze48rdua8u2sy

The node-engine asked the catalog for a trunk build it had none of at every composition pass, which added to the catalog's load while it was choked. - A trunk build the catalog gave none of is asked again on a backoff, or at once when `mesh-catalog.catalog-revision` is heard; never at every pass (A-487a). - A refused catalog-revision subscription is said once and tried again; it never refuses the watch. - The manifest consumes `mesh-catalog.catalog-revision`; one test, a subtest of an existing test. Lead answer: hq `03-DESIGN/01-to-be/47-milestones/` A-487a (hq #717). Hears the event the catalog publishes from mesh-delivery fix/catalog-answers-from-memory; without it the backoff alone holds. Manifest validator (indexer `judge`, run locally): mesh-host accepted alone; on the shelf it adds no problem against main (what it still refuses, the seats `mesh-grants` and `mesh-recovery`, it refuses on main the same way, because the validator's seat list lacks them). Known failure on main, not this change: `TestTheNodeComposesItsWantsFromTheBus` under -race. Reviewed-by: review-487@shanks at 85d1707e829f3708b99db4436353e71910ac656a https://claude.ai/code/session_01JG73KHUnBze48rdua8u2sy
mesh-tools added 4 commits 2026-11-19 10:47:45 +00:00
A trunk build answered none waits laterAgain's step for its module (5 s growing to 5 min); the seat mesh-catalog's
event catalog-revision, heard through Env.Hear, ends the wait of every module at once; an answer starts the steps
again. A pass is woken at the step's end.

Builds: design 47 G-22 A-487a, A-461e, G-12 line 317
The subscription is a wake-up; the backoff bounds the asks without it. The refusal is said with its subject and error
(principle 3), the composer goes on, and the subscription is tried again on laterAgain's steps until it holds.

Builds: design 47 G-22 A-487a, principle 3
Subscribe to meshcatalog.SubjectCatalogRevisionAll (no string of its own); module.json consumes
mesh-catalog.catalog-revision so the node account is granted it; the two new tests are folded into
TestTrunkAskBackoffAndCatalogRevision and wait on channels, not time.

Builds: design 47 G-22 A-487a, A-487c, principle 3
Builds: design 47 G-22 A-487a, the test budget (module total back to main's count)
mesh-tools merged commit 3e17fc939d into main 2026-11-19 10:49:10 +00:00
mesh-tools deleted branch fix/trunk-ask-backoff 2026-11-19 10:49:10 +00:00
Author
Member

{
"records": [
{
"instance": "record/main_1024_1aea1eb9/8a64be5c424bee7d",
"sequence": 10155,
"bytes": 2347,
"of-bytes": 262144,
"waits": "its difference is not known yet",
"record": {
"milestone": "main.1024",
"heads": {
"novox/mesh-host@238": "3e17fc939d75700d61e33d567a0c6056f79d96d0"
},
"opened": "2026-11-19T10:55:29.15996113Z",
"form": 1,
"group": {
"group": "",
"members": [
"novox/mesh-catalog@703",
"novox/mesh-delivery@251",
"novox/mesh-host@238"
],
"pulls": [
{
"repository": "novox/mesh-host",
"number": 238,
"head": "3e17fc939d75700d61e33d567a0c6056f79d96d0",
"state": "merged",
"commit": "3e17fc939d75700d61e33d567a0c6056f79d96d0"
}
]
},
"entries": {
"mesh-delivery-gate|src2:cf9de6b8b18e3ddfc74b52aae3364a4b6886caf70642a33fc0c5a4d72fe93efd|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-gate|src2:cf9de6b8b18e3ddfc74b52aae3364a4b6886caf70642a33fc0c5a4d72fe93efd|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-gate",
"fingerprint": "src2:cf9de6b8b18e3ddfc74b52aae3364a4b6886caf70642a33fc0c5a4d72fe93efd"
},
"mesh-delivery-pipeline|src2:2458e378974fc447e7844ab5300c419fead8322c9aa073b233fd726c4647644f|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-pipeline|src2:2458e378974fc447e7844ab5300c419fead8322c9aa073b233fd726c4647644f|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-pipeline",
"fingerprint": "src2:2458e378974fc447e7844ab5300c419fead8322c9aa073b233fd726c4647644f"
},
"mesh-delivery-view|src2:2c9492a312223f8c063731f2a570df2b186c1e8b5041bdf9083a70ba0fa76272|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-view|src2:2c9492a312223f8c063731f2a570df2b186c1e8b5041bdf9083a70ba0fa76272|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-view",
"fingerprint": "src2:2c9492a312223f8c063731f2a570df2b186c1e8b5041bdf9083a70ba0fa76272"
},
"mesh-delivery-watchman|src2:b1ad9112ca98087eb0e10c8b3405c351b7905a7150596bc1d8cee49ca85e0195|": {
"key": "mesh-delivery-watchman|src2:b1ad9112ca98087eb0e10c8b3405c351b7905a7150596bc1d8cee49ca85e0195|",
"module": "mesh-delivery-watchman",
"fingerprint": "src2:b1ad9112ca98087eb0e10c8b3405c351b7905a7150596bc1d8cee49ca85e0195"
},
"mesh-host|src2:4b172809961587706ee3581a1bcb38e2a385ec17085ee9cb83cda10fbeb6f4f2|": {
"key": "mesh-host|src2:4b172809961587706ee3581a1bcb38e2a385ec17085ee9cb83cda10fbeb6f4f2|",
"module": "mesh-host",
"fingerprint": "src2:4b172809961587706ee3581a1bcb38e2a385ec17085ee9cb83cda10fbeb6f4f2"
}
},
"outcomes": {
"|||take-in": {
"key": "|||take-in",
"module": "",
"step": "take-in",
"outcome": "taken-in",
"why": "lead-47@shanks: revision held since 2026-11-18 02:11 for indexer build src2:4da92308, which never runs (own build a0a26664); holds six merges incl. mesh-delivery #251 and mesh-host #238; A-476 in #250/#251 removes this hold",
"at": "2026-11-19T10:55:29.158345617Z"
}
}
}
}
]
}

<!-- mesh-delivery:view --> { "records": [ { "instance": "record/main_1024_1aea1eb9/8a64be5c424bee7d", "sequence": 10155, "bytes": 2347, "of-bytes": 262144, "waits": "its difference is not known yet", "record": { "milestone": "main.1024", "heads": { "novox/mesh-host@238": "3e17fc939d75700d61e33d567a0c6056f79d96d0" }, "opened": "2026-11-19T10:55:29.15996113Z", "form": 1, "group": { "group": "", "members": [ "novox/mesh-catalog@703", "novox/mesh-delivery@251", "novox/mesh-host@238" ], "pulls": [ { "repository": "novox/mesh-host", "number": 238, "head": "3e17fc939d75700d61e33d567a0c6056f79d96d0", "state": "merged", "commit": "3e17fc939d75700d61e33d567a0c6056f79d96d0" } ] }, "entries": { "mesh-delivery-gate|src2:cf9de6b8b18e3ddfc74b52aae3364a4b6886caf70642a33fc0c5a4d72fe93efd|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-gate|src2:cf9de6b8b18e3ddfc74b52aae3364a4b6886caf70642a33fc0c5a4d72fe93efd|", "module": "mesh-delivery-gate", "fingerprint": "src2:cf9de6b8b18e3ddfc74b52aae3364a4b6886caf70642a33fc0c5a4d72fe93efd" }, "mesh-delivery-pipeline|src2:2458e378974fc447e7844ab5300c419fead8322c9aa073b233fd726c4647644f|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-pipeline|src2:2458e378974fc447e7844ab5300c419fead8322c9aa073b233fd726c4647644f|", "module": "mesh-delivery-pipeline", "fingerprint": "src2:2458e378974fc447e7844ab5300c419fead8322c9aa073b233fd726c4647644f" }, "mesh-delivery-view|src2:2c9492a312223f8c063731f2a570df2b186c1e8b5041bdf9083a70ba0fa76272|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-view|src2:2c9492a312223f8c063731f2a570df2b186c1e8b5041bdf9083a70ba0fa76272|", "module": "mesh-delivery-view", "fingerprint": "src2:2c9492a312223f8c063731f2a570df2b186c1e8b5041bdf9083a70ba0fa76272" }, "mesh-delivery-watchman|src2:b1ad9112ca98087eb0e10c8b3405c351b7905a7150596bc1d8cee49ca85e0195|": { "key": "mesh-delivery-watchman|src2:b1ad9112ca98087eb0e10c8b3405c351b7905a7150596bc1d8cee49ca85e0195|", "module": "mesh-delivery-watchman", "fingerprint": "src2:b1ad9112ca98087eb0e10c8b3405c351b7905a7150596bc1d8cee49ca85e0195" }, "mesh-host|src2:4b172809961587706ee3581a1bcb38e2a385ec17085ee9cb83cda10fbeb6f4f2|": { "key": "mesh-host|src2:4b172809961587706ee3581a1bcb38e2a385ec17085ee9cb83cda10fbeb6f4f2|", "module": "mesh-host", "fingerprint": "src2:4b172809961587706ee3581a1bcb38e2a385ec17085ee9cb83cda10fbeb6f4f2" } }, "outcomes": { "|||take-in": { "key": "|||take-in", "module": "", "step": "take-in", "outcome": "taken-in", "why": "lead-47@shanks: revision held since 2026-11-18 02:11 for indexer build src2:4da92308, which never runs (own build a0a26664); holds six merges incl. mesh-delivery #251 and mesh-host #238; A-476 in #250/#251 removes this hold", "at": "2026-11-19T10:55:29.158345617Z" } } } } ] } <!-- mesh-act:view.record/main_1024_1aea1eb9/8a64be5c424bee7d.novox/mesh-host#238@1795085732556702181.140f86ee -->
Sign in to join this conversation.
No Reviewers
1 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: novox/mesh-host#238