The bed set no node a `public-domain` and assigned no `acme-ca` provider, so it
was testing a mesh the design no longer describes — and going green while doing
it, which is the worse half.
**No public domain means no route.** A module now contributes a `label` and
nothing else; the mesh joins it to the node's public domain, and a label with no
domain to join composes to nothing at all. Every routed module on this bed was
therefore unreachable by name, silently, and no assertion noticed. novox now
carries `novox.incus` and ace `zurag.incus` — `.incus`, because this repository's
beds name nothing routable. The workstations carry none, which is also the design
being exercised: a node that does not face outward has no public domain.
**No acme-ca provider means no proxy.** route-proxy requires one, so without a
provider it is unresolvable and takes every routed module with it. step-ca is
assigned on the anchor, at mesh scope, and given an operator root — made with
openssl on the anchor and handed over through the real `secret accept` path,
because the mesh cannot invent a PEM and the random bytes it makes for an
own-secret nobody supplied would leave the CA crash-looping on a root key that is
not a key.
**What is asserted is the half that is decided and cheap**: that each routed
module's name composes to `<label>.<public-domain>` — read from the proxy's own
received-routes file, the mesh's answer on the machine rather than this test's
arithmetic checked against itself — with `@` composing to the bare domain, and
that the proxy answers for one of them over HTTP.
**What is NOT asserted is issuance.** Whether route-proxy obtains a certificate
from step-ca over ACME depends on mesh-control fixes landing as this is written,
and a bed that gated on them would report somebody else's in-flight work as its
own failure. step-ca is listed as a reported gap for the same reason.
The substrate apply also retries up to three times. `raise` now refuses to return
until every machine can fetch a manifest from the scenario registry, so the first
attempt should be the only one; a pull is simply the one step here that can fail
for a reason that goes away by itself, and the cost of not retrying was a whole
raise left as a bare shell.
Typechecks; not run end-to-end — see the ADR 0056 section for what is expected to
fail until the issuance path is fixed.
The first whole-mesh raise of the ADR 0056 code died on the anchor's substrate
apply: the image pulls failed, the anchor never came up, no node could enrol,
and the instance was left a bare shell — VMs and a registry, no substrate. The
identical apply, run by hand once the registry was warm, succeeded immediately.
`raiseRegistry` proves the wrong thing. It curls `localhost:5000` from inside
the registry's OWN machine, which says the registry process is up and holds the
blobs, and says nothing about the path anybody else uses: across a segment, and
for the home nodes through a NAT gateway whose default route and firewall are
applied two steps LATER. So "serving" was reported on evidence that excluded the
network, and the caller — which pins every image in the substrate bundle to that
registry — was handed a fact it could not rely on.
So the check moves to where it means something. After the routes and the
firewalls, before the minutes spent placing, each machine is asked for `/v2/` and
for one stocked manifest BY DIGEST, at the address it will pin, over the network
it will use. That is the pair of requests a pull begins with, from the same
place. Layers are not fetched: every digest was already read back inside the
registry machine, so what is in question here is the path, not the content.
Verified by typecheck and the unit suite (136 pass), and by confirming against a
standing four-node instance that `curl` exists in the machines and that both
segments — including a home node through the gateway — answer 200 for the
registry's `/v2/`. The ordering itself is unverified in a live raise from cold,
which takes hours.
ADR 0056 made `acme-ca` a requirement of route-proxy, and step-ca is what
answers it. A scenario that does not stock the image cannot run the CA, the
proxy does not resolve, and every routed module on the mesh goes with it.
This was carried as an uncommitted edit through the first ADR 0056 raise. Kept,
because it is right, and committed, because a fix that lives in somebody's
working tree is a fix the next raise does not have.
Rewrite the flat three-node whole-mesh-full (separate anchor, one public segment)
into production's real shape: two segments and one access point. novox sits on
the routable `hosting` segment and IS the anchor — it runs the substrate, its own
service set, the overlay hub and public ingress; there is no separate anchor node.
ace, shanks and g14 sit on the household `home` segment behind a NAT gateway,
reachable from outside only through what they dial out to.
The bed drives, and verifies, the thing the flat beds never could: the WireGuard
overlay forming ACROSS the access point — a home node dialling novox's public hub
endpoint out through the gateway's masquerade, the handshake completing through the
NAT, the keepalive holding the hole open. Phase A proves it (handshake state + a
ping over the overlay) before any heavy module lands; Phase B converges both server
sets. With MESH_LAB_KEEP the instance is raised under a fixed id and left standing.
Collapsing the substrate onto novox exposed real facts the separate-anchor beds
never hit, fixed here:
- the substrate bundle advertises the broker at 192.0.2.10 (the old anchor); a
token carries that verbatim as the endpoint a node dials, so with the substrate
on novox it must be novox's own public address. Rewritten at apply (the cert is
fingerprint-pinned, not hostname-checked, so only the address needs correcting).
- the two provider host-port collisions with the co-located substrate: postgres
5432 vs the store's 127.0.0.1:5432, lavinmq 5672 vs the broker's 127.0.0.1:5672.
Both provider host publishes are remapped off the substrate's ports.
And a lab limitation this first large-union bed exposed: the image registry VM took
the profile's default `dir` pool and a ~10GiB root, which the ~28GiB union of both
server sets overflows ("no space left on device"). raiseRegistry now places the
registry on the scenario's copy-on-write pool with a sized (default 80GiB, thin)
root disk, MESH_LAB_REGISTRY_DISK overridable.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Re-runs the capstone from main after the dry-run fixes merged.
fail2ban: added to the novox set. The capability fix (intrusion-prevention ->
firewall) makes it HOSTABLE — it is now assigned, not refused — which is the
gate. Its service reaching active is a host concern the offline lab cannot meet
(the VM ships nftables but not fail2ban, and the isolated segment has no route to
the package mirror, so pacman cannot fetch it), so fail2ban joins GAPS_NOVOX: its
failed package resource is tolerated like firewall's oneshot nftables.service.
7 credential sidecars: before the push, a FAKE app credential is delivered for
each (plex/bazarr/ombi/home-assistant/nzbget/qbittorrent on ace, umami on novox)
through the real operator path — `secret accept <node> <module> <name> --from`.
The bed asserts each sidecar advances PAST its old "no credential" crash (it reads
the delivered value); app-auth failure against the real app with a bogus value is
expected and not gated.
Result: SUITE_EXIT=0. Both node-plans converge on one substrate (novox 13/13
core, ace 17/17 core), fail2ban hostable, all 7 sidecars past their crash.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Combine the novox (17-module) and ace (24-module) sets on ONE substrate and
prove both node-plans converge together. anchor runs the substrate only;
novox and ace each run their own self-contained set (own postgres/redis), so
nothing crosses a node boundary except enrolment and the shared broker/store.
The four modules both nodes run (postgres, redis, mssql, portainer) are added
once and assigned to each node, each getting its own per-node broker account.
An overlay is placed across all three nodes.
Proven green: both nodes converge together on the one substrate. ace reaches
applied+current with all 17 of its CORE up (and letta too this run); novox
reaches all 13 CORE up with its only failed resource the known firewall.load
oneshot gap. The two node-plans share one broker without collision — distinct
novox-<mod> and ace-<mod> accounts for the modules both run. No new cross-node
bug (overlay/DNS/identity/port) surfaced; ports are per-VM and the sets are
node-self-contained. Tolerates the same nine credential-sidecar gaps and
firewall's nftables.service oneshot documented in the per-server beds.
Resource envelope: 3 VMs (anchor 4GiB, novox 16GiB, ace 18GiB) + registry
scenery, ~79 union images (~35GB) stocked to one registry VM and pulled
concurrently by both nodes; fit within 125GiB host RAM and the 180GiB lab pool.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Install the real ace server's converted service set (24 modules) together on
one node behind the substrate — sibling of the whole-mesh-novox bed, the
media/home-automation half. Loads each committed module.json from
mesh-catalog, rewrites image refs to the scenario registry's digests, remaps
the co-located host-port collisions (qbittorrent/searxng/unifi :8080,
nzbget/unifi :6789), and pre-creates the ADR-0051 operator-owned media
library dirs under /services/media so the media stack's `accesses` resolve.
Proven green: the whole 24-module set RESOLVES and applies (214 resources,
node applied+current) — the ADR-0051 shared-dir `accesses` mechanism works
cleanly across eight co-accessing media modules. The CORE 17 converge whole:
postgres/redis/mssql, sonarr/radarr/lidarr/jackett/tautulli/bookshelf,
mosquitto/influxdb/grafana/baserow/nodered/searxng/unifi/portainer.
Reported as escalated gaps (do not gate green): six tool-runtime sidecars
crash-loop because the committed manifest does not wire the app credential
they need (plex MESH_PLEX_TOKEN, bazarr MESH_BAZARR_API_KEY, nzbget
MESH_NZBGET_URL/PASSWORD, qbittorrent MESH_QBITTORRENT_URL/PASSWORD, ombi
MESH_OMBI_API_KEY, home-assistant MESH_HOMEASSISTANT_TOKEN) — the umami/photos
class from novox; each server is up, only the sidecar is down. sonarr/radarr/
lidarr/jackett/tautulli self-configure from the app's config file and their
runtimes come up. letta's app has a first-boot postgres migration race
(pgvector the deeper blocker, per two-node-db).
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Install the real novox server's converted service set together on one node
behind the substrate — the whole-catalogue install this rebuild never ran.
The bed loads each committed module.json from mesh-catalog (no hand-written
manifests), rewrites image refs to the scenario registry's digests, and
remaps the co-located host-port collisions (nextcloud/invoicing/route-proxy
:80, minio/invoicing :9000, gitea/umami :3000).
Proven green: the whole set of 17 modules RESOLVES and applies (191
resources); the CORE 13 converge whole — all five providers (postgres,
redis, minio, mongodb, mssql) plus keycloak, gitea, nextcloud and invoicing
reaching their providers and staying up, plus portainer, verdaccio, registry
and route-proxy.
Reported as escalated gaps (do not gate green): fail2ban (declares
capability intrusion-prevention that no host detector provides, and an
unappliable assignment blocks whole-node resolution), umami/photos/mailu
(catalog manifests do not wire the runtime/app env the images need; photos'
server image is an alpine placeholder), and firewall (nftables.service is a
oneshot that exits, but the module declares state running so mesh-host marks
it failed).
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
A single-node VM bed: an ollama provider and a local-model consumer are
assigned; the resolver answers the consumer's model-access with the local node
(no licence demanded), the consumer's openai.env is templated with the served
endpoint, and a request to it reaches the running model server. Proves the
node-answer of model-access end to end (ollama on host network, keyless).
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
A single-node VM bed: the operator sets an API key on an openai licence, the
mesh seals it to the consumer, the host unseals and mounts it, and the consumer
writes it as OPENAI_API_KEY (env + Codex auth.json). Asserts the written key
equals the one set — the other shape ADR 0050 defines, and the ADR 0054 branch
where a static-key vendor records no usage. Green on the first run.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
A VM bed: a postgres provider and the model-usage consumer on one node, the
substrate on the other. A usage event injected into the mesh is upserted into
model-usage's provisioned store, asserted at both grains, latest-per-key, and
in the clear.
Also, in build-module-runtime.sh, add migrate/index.ts and pg.d.ts to the
compiled entrypoint set so a module may carry a run-once entry and an ambient
type declaration (model-usage uses the latter for the pg driver).
The bed surfaced and drove several fixes elsewhere: a short module slug for the
S3-key identity bound (ADR 0049), host-network containers getting the mesh's
names (mesh-control), and injecting the event from a publisher rather than the
pure-consumer store (its account has no publish right by design).
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Two harness fixes the green end-to-end run needed:
- build-module-runtime.sh installs a module's non-@novox runtime deps under
/app/modules/<module>/node_modules, so a module can carry a private dependency
(the anthropic-manager seals with tweetnacl-sealedbox-js). The shared tree still
answers @novox/* and common packages. A no-op for modules that declare none.
- stageIntoControl chmods the manager's 0600 adopt/refresh outputs to 0644 on the
anchor host before docker cp, so the distroless mesh-control (non-root, no chmod)
can read the staged file. What is staged is a sealed box or the access token,
never a cleartext refresh token.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
The bed follows the reworked flow: the manager module seals the refresh token to the node's
PUBLIC key, the HOST unseals it and mounts the cleartext at the manager's bound path, and the
refresh reads that cleartext -- no fake node key pair is mounted any more, the host uses its
own real sealing key.
- the manager is a model-access holder deployed first, so its bound facts (carrying the node
public key) are delivered; the consumer is added only once an access token exists to seal.
- adopt reads the node public key from the bound facts; the test asserts the host mounts the
cleartext refresh token for the manager, and that it reaches nowhere on the consuming node.
- the refresh_grant assertion reads { sealed, manager_key }.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
A lab bed for Phase C of model-access (ADR 0050), OAuth endpoint stubbed.
It drives the real runtime images through the whole flow: the manager
seals a refresh token at rest and opens it on the manager node alone,
mesh-control is handed only the access token and an opaque re-sealed
envelope via licence submit-refresh, and the consumer writes an
access-token-only credential. Asserts the refresh token -- original and
rotated -- is nowhere on the consuming node and only ciphertext in the
control plane's database.
build-module-runtime.sh also compiles adopt/refresh/apply/usage
entrypoints. Stubbed and flagged: the vendor endpoint, the manager node's
private key (mounted; a host capability to deliver it does not exist
today), and the submit transport (the test invokes the CLI on the
manager's output).
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Two-node: substrate broker on anchor, lavinmq provider + amqp-ping consumer on laptop. The
consumer gets its scoped vhost+user, connects, and round-trips a message. Requires the
mesh-control require-only-mint fix. Diagnostic removed now it's green. SUITE_EXIT=0.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
The lavinmq AMQP provider comes up and serves, but its receives file has given:[] — the
consumer amqp-ping (requires amqp, contributes nothing, as a parameterless provision like
redis-cache takes no per-consumer payload) is never minted a credential, so the provisioner
creates no vhost. Diagnostic in the test dumps the empty grants file + the provisioner log.
This is the resolve/plan mint path (grantsFor -> SecretsFrom), ADR 0048 territory, and it
likely affects redis-cache consumers the same way. Preserved for a focused fix; not merged.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
A lavinmq provider and an amqp-ping consumer ride laptop while the
substrate's own broker owns 5672 on anchor — the twin of two-node-db.
lavinmq is the mesh's control broker AND a user-facing capability, so a
provider must publish 5672 for its consumers and cannot share a node
with the control broker that already owns it; the split unblocks the
chain single-node.
The bed proves, layered: the run-once bootstrap computed the admin hash
and wrote the broker config before the broker started (ADR 0052); the
service and both runtimes are up and stable; each module got its scoped
broker account on the substrate broker; the provisioner created the
consumer's vhost AND user, both named for the derived login; and the
consumer connected to that vhost with the mesh-minted password and
round-tripped a message. The consumer uses ${bound:amqp:as} for user
and vhost both, and the provider's serves carries the port.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
A scenario and integration test assign route-proxy (provider) and hello-web
(consumer) on one node, then assert a request to the consumer's name -- sent to
the proxy -- is forwarded to the workload and returns its answer, and that
unassigning the consumer withdraws the route so the same request stops working
(the proxy replaces its table rather than merging). Modeled on
mesh-grant-end-to-end and schedule-tick: module add, assign, one push, settled,
with no module issue (route-proxy needs no scoped account).
build-route-proxy-image.sh compiles the Go proxy from
mesh-control/examples/route-proxy into mesh-route-proxy:development for the
scenario to stock. This bed proves route-forwarding over plain HTTP;
public-ACME TLS is proven separately by certificates.test.ts against a real
ACME server.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
The bed that proves the scheduled-container primitive end to end. schedtest
is the thinnest carrier of ADR 0053: one container marked
schedule: "* * * * *" that appends a timestamp to a mounted data dir each
time the host fires it -- no service, no listener, no provisioner, no
runtime, no tools, no events.
The three claims it proves, from the ADR's "How each claim is checked":
installing the schedule leaves the node current WITHOUT a run (baseline
captured right after settled, the deliberate inversion of run-once); the
container fires on its cadence (a line beyond the baseline within ~150s);
and it recurs (a second line on the next minute -- cadence, not a one-shot).
schedtest serves and consumes nothing and carries no runtime, so it is not
issued a broker account: module add -> assign -> one push is the whole
sequence, no module issue. The tick image is a bare alpine served by the
scenario's registry by digest.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
The GREEN multi-node regression bed that proves the DB-consumer gate: substrate/control on
one node, postgres+redis providers and baserow+letta consumers on another, each consumer
getting its own credential and its own mesh-named database across the overlay. Requires the
mesh-control provider-seal-key fix and the mesh-catalog db-name fix.
Includes a general lab capability: a machine 'disk' field sizing the VM root disk (a broad
install exhausts the pool default and the host fails mid-apply with 'no space left on
device'). The bed sets 60GiB.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Sixth green regression bed. Same shape as tools-gitlab: a runtime-only module comes
up under the mesh, serves its full tool surface with no valid credentials (the Servarr
lesson), stays up, binds its serve queues, and gets its scoped broker account.
SUITE_EXIT=0.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Prove gitlab — the exemplar tools-only, outbound-only external-SaaS
integration — installs: a scenario assigning gitlab to one node, and a test
asserting the mesh-runtime-gitlab container comes up and stays up, logs
[mesh-tools] serving 23 tool(s), binds its serve queues on the broker, and
gets its own scoped account — all with NO valid GitLab token, the case the
Servarr lesson is about.
No gitlab arm is needed in build-module-runtime.sh: gitlab speaks HTTP and
needs no extra CLI in the image.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
A bed that assigns mosquitto and asserts the run-once step seeded dynsec
before the broker: the bootstrap ran to completion (not left running), the
seed is on disk owned by the broker's uid, the broker is up and stable
(it crash-loops against an unseeded store, so a stable broker is the proof),
and the node reached current. On top, the seeded admin authenticates over
MQTT and the provisioner grants a scoped client a consumer connects with.
build-module-runtime.sh gains a mosquitto arm (install mosquitto_ctrl from
the mosquitto package — it is not in mosquitto-clients on bookworm, and a
musl binary from eclipse-mosquitto would not load) and compiles the module's
bootstrap/index.ts entrypoint.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
sonarr and radarr both access /services/media/downloads — the exact duplicate path
the resolver refused before novox/hq ADR 0051 (04-ISSUES/036, 012). Each now declares
it as an `access`, not a `directory` resource, so the pair co-resolves and one push
configures both. The operator provides the shared media dirs before apply (the host
refuses an absent access); the bed creates them after enrol and before the push.
Proves: the push is not refused, the node converges once, both modules' server and
runtime containers are up, and both server containers mount the same operator-owned
spool.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Adds the mongodb runtime CLI (mongosh) to build-module-runtime.sh, a
catalogue-apps scenario, and its install test. Proven so far: the ADR-0054 slug
applies and the mesh accepts the push (mongodb consumer identity mesh_anchor_mongo
fits). NOT green: the node applies but never reaches 'current' within 1200s — a
persistent reconcile divergence (applied-but-never-current, no crash), likely a
module declaring a resource its container mutates (issue-011 class). Needs live
VM inspection to name the module. Not merged.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Raises the first-node substrate and assigns postgres, minio, redis and
plex to one anchor in a single push, proving they resolve and come up
together on one node. postgres and minio each get a consumer that
connects with a real granted credential.
redis follows the corrected provider contract (ADR 0048, issue 032): its
runtime reconciles the contributions the mesh delivers at MESH_RECEIVES
and creates each consumer's ACL user with the mesh-minted password,
sealing nothing — no MESH_SEAL_KEY, no *.grant.json/*.credential path.
The provisioning proof authenticates as the consumer with the mesh's
password (PONG), matching the green provider-uses-mesh-credential bed.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Issue 010 fixed: bucketuser declares slug `bkt`, so its identity mesh_anchor_bkt (15)
fits an S3 access key where mesh_anchor_bucketuser (22) did not. Unskips the test.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Mirrors the postgres bed for minio: a provider (runtime carries mc) + a consumer
requiring s3-bucket, proving the consumer reaches its bucket with the access key and
secret the mesh delivered. It surfaced a real limit: the mesh derives `as` =
mesh_<node>_<module> (22 chars), and an S3 access key is capped at 20, so minio refuses
the service account. The test is correct and skipped pending 04-ISSUES/010, not worked
around.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Assigns a postgres provider (its runtime carries psql) and a module that requires
postgres-database; the mesh mints one password, postgres's provisioner creates a role
and database under the mesh's login with it, and the consumer connects to its database
with the delivered credential (a password-checked connection) — select 1. Nothing placed
by the test. The postgres half of the per-backend provider proof (ADR 0052/0053).
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Assigns a redis provider and a module that requires redis-cache; the mesh mints one
password, seals a copy to each end, writes redis its contributions and the consumer
its bound file, and the host unseals each side. redis's provisioner creates the ACL
user under the mesh's login with the mesh's password, and the consumer's delivered
credential authenticates (PONG). Nothing is placed by the test — the provider/consumer
contract (ADR 0053) working as one thing, no shared key anywhere.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
build-module-runtime.sh adds psql to the postgres image and mc to the minio image
(their clients shell out to those). provider-on-backend-network asserts redis's
runtime, on the backend's private network, binds the broker via NAT and provisions
a consumer with the mesh's credential — the shape the committed provider manifests use.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
Assigns redis as a provider, puts the contributions and unsealed password the mesh
would deliver in its receives path, and authenticates as the consumer with the mesh's
password — PONG proves the login was created with exactly that password (a
self-generated one answers WRONGPASS), with MESH_SEAL_KEY set nowhere.
Claude-Session: https://claude.ai/code/session_01LrgweAeERJYBg88c5cKDzF
jschoubben