mesh/delivery-group group fix/403-fix-time checking: composed check out of date: novox/mesh-controller@7ca5a45ecc5a was judged against trunk ?, the trunk is no…
The forge refuses an approval of one's own pull request, so the independent
reviews are comment reviews opening with "Verdict: approve at <sha>"; read
only APPROVED, the review phase was never measured. A fix whose start was
read back from the log was fixed before fix times were measured: it is kept
and shown, never warned on. A carried value at fixing after one at diagnosing
starts at its worker's active (the move), not its since (the diagnosis).
mesh/merge-gate pass: builds mesh-delivery, mesh-issues → novox; no bus step; every machine composes with the change as it did without (4 of 4 compose)
hq ADR 0313: the operator's five minutes start when an agent moves the issue
to fixing, not at the merge. mesh-delivery says on each transition, and in
checks, when the pull request opened, when it merged and the class of what it
moves. mesh-issues keeps the first move to fixing, the fix time with its four
phases once the last fix is delivered, serves fix-times, and says
issue-tracker.fix.<class>.over-budget on the operator's channel, cleared by the
next fix of that class within budget.
mesh/merge-gate pass: builds betterbird, sent nowhere; no bus step; 1 wait(s) for a person; every machine composes with the change as it did without (4 of …
The shared-server check refused an adopted account for its own alias, and
counted Owl's, local folders' and feeds' identities as users of the default
server, though they never send by SMTP. The controller now judges an
upstream pin's host like any name, so each pin declares its vendor.
The user.js answer carried declared addresses and hosts (ADR 0316 §16). An
adopted identity's outgoing server may be shared with an account the module
does not own, whose sending the declared values would change at every start:
refused with the remedy, since ADR 0317 §2 leaves the identity's server and
the lists as they are; a recorded adoption follows the identity's current
server. Owl installed by policy cannot be removed, so a newer Owl than the
pin is a fact whose remedy is moving the pin.
A module that cannot set Betterbird up is of little use (the operator,
2026-10-12). The module now declares the community package absent and
unpacks the pinned upstream release where that package had it, so the same
profile opens; places the enterprise policy that turns Betterbird's updater
off and force-installs Owl from the xpi the mesh pinned by its vendor's
digest (never in a repository); and takes the operator's accounts from the
trusted setting accounts, without any password or token: an account the
profile already holds is adopted under its own keys, a new one is created
under the module's mesh_ keys, an ambiguous one is refused with the remedy,
and the account lists are only written into. betterbird_accounts says the
profile's accounts by count and proposes the setting built from them for the
operator's Approve. Every new build waits for the operator's push. The
reminder test is visibly a test (MESH TEST band, event name) and its
description says it opens a window on the operator's screen.
A fresh profile has never checked for updates, so Betterbird checked at the
test's start, found a newer build published and opened its About window on the
operator's screen instead of leaving the reminder to show. The test's own
preferences now also come last in its user.js, so nothing declared or carried
overrides them.
No record names an image the mesh did not make, so one a definition pins under an
older name of the store read as unrecorded, the same word as an image nothing
uses. The tool now reads every definition through the catalogue and says
named-by-a-definition with the module. The store's older names are the mesh's
setting older-store-names, since a catalogue names no installation.
delivery_status said only what is owed now; issue 326's rule needs the tries made in a window.
It now says the tries since this owner started, by how each ended, and the last try's time.
(novox/hq issue 407)
A changes link onto a drafted clause was refused, so records that really
change such a rule could only cite it (ADR 0294, 0301, 0320); and return
renumbered ADR 0281's clauses, pointing other records' links at other
clauses. The changed drafted clause keeps its number and stays unserved;
return refuses a record whose clauses another record changed or links by
number. Issue 494, ADR 0321.
A stop for a walk that never built its modules (issue 474) kept saying "error: stopped" on the forge and in
show after a later delivered merge carried its change to every machine. The stop stays final, as a covered
superseded member stays superseded (issue 442); its status, view, note and show now say covered and by which
merge, told once and from what is kept, so a restart or a stop covered before this tells it too. deliveries
dropped such a stop after a day while stalled still listed it; it now lists it as long as stalled does.
novox/hq issue 480, points 1 and 3.
A replaced ask's message was left open as if the newer ask took it over, but
the newer ask opens a message of its own, so the old one kept offering answers
nobody takes. It now ends on every channel with 'Replaced by a newer question',
and the minute's sweep ends any such message left from before. A record that
clears no longer keeps what a walk owed of it (the review of PR 238).
A warning held on purpose and lost with the walk's message at a restart was turned
into history and never told. Name the walk in the told line from its own item.
A resolved issue's worker proved the acceptance live, so a fix whose own walk failed
and that a later merge carried is not waited for. Only wontfix ended the warning, so
16 warnings stayed open on the operator's channel and the sweep raised new ones for
resolved issues.
A message lost with a restart before it was sent left what it carried marked told,
so it reached the operator only as its reminder hours later. A later walk took over
silenced, already said or asked messages that ADR 0308 section 3 never holds. A start
capped at the router's now was compared with the controller's moments.
The operator decided on 2026-10-12 that a rule of the record set that fails
is a fault of the records, which their authors repair, not the module
failing: as issue 508 decided for a proposal never reviewed, health says
only whether the module works, and a finding must not hold the module's
own rollouts. The findings go through the notice the knowledge base
already sends (operator-channel.notify, a warning), once per finding,
kept as told across restarts, and cleared when the rule holds again.
inZone wrote time.Local while the bus test's nats server read it from a
goroutine that outlives its test; the race detector the repository check
now runs failed TestAReviewOwedOutlivesARestartAndItsLastTryIsSaid.
The whole-set rule cited ran only after acceptance: the review approved a
decision with no home and no record linking it, the rule then failed, and
the module's health turned red for a fault its author could only repair
after the fact. hq held the rule at the record's own merge. The review now
judges it ahead, before the judgement: such a decision stays proposed with
a changes finding naming the rule. It is not refused at propose, because
no record can link a number only reserved.
Review 30 found guard.ts missing branches the forge protects: Go reads \d, \w,
\pL, a class opening with ] or ^, and [[:digit:]] otherwise than JavaScript.
A rule using any of them now covers every branch, so the guard refuses more
than the forge, never less. test/rule-cases.json holds the forge's answers,
read by the Go and TypeScript tests alike.
The forge's contents and diffpatch endpoints take a branch, never a commit to
build on, so the parent is read from the commit the forge made, and a branch
that moved under the commit is said. Blobs are read at the commit read first,
not at the branch name. Protection rules match as Gitea 1.27 matches them
([...], {a,b}, escapes, a plain name in any case), in the Go bundle and in
guard.ts alike. One commit carries at most 4 MiB per file or patch and 16 MiB
together; code search stops at its deadline and says so. The HTTP client the
two Go bundles copied is one package, internal/forgehttp.
The recheck's pending was written from the tools' bundle, its own process, past the
writer's per-head chain: the first run's verdict mark stayed set, so a rechecked head
never said where its new run builds, and an old run's verdict in flight or redelivered
could land over the pending. The status tool is now served from the watcher's bundle
and writes the merge check's pending through the writer, and a verdict whose ask
(checked.id) predates the check now pending is dropped, weighed after a restart against
the forge's own history of the gate (novox/hq issue 456).
mesh/merge-gate pass: builds nats, sent nowhere; merging this needs a person's bus upgrade; 1 wait(s) for a person; every machine composes with the change …
nats_user_can read the user list on the machine. A list written is not a list the bus enforces until
the server reloads it: on 2026-10-09 the controller asked between the write and the reload's effect.
The answer now carries in_force — allowed in the file, and the server's config_load_time after the
file's write — with why when it is not, and anything not known is not in force.
- No channel ready at a walk's end or bound: what it held is left unsent and tried
again every minute, as any other message, instead of lost with the walk.
- At a walk's end or bound, a message another open walk touches is held on by
that walk, even one started after it was held (hq ADR 0308 §2).
- A walk read back past its forget is released at its bound first, then forgotten.
- A walk's end is kept a day: a start heard after it (same started_at, or not
later than the end) opens nothing, also after the router restarts; a later
start under the same id still opens.
- A walk's plain end, when its words cannot be said, leaves what it held to be
said on its own instead of marking it told.
- The restart pass no longer skips a held message: one with an open ask is never
held (ADR 0308 §3), so its answers are made to work again.
An agent could not get a finished change onto the forge without someone
pushing by hand, so the branch / pull request / approval rule could not be
followed. A Go bundle serves gitea_commit, held to gitea_api's rule (never the
default branch, never a protected one), and the summarised reads agents
otherwise made through gitea_api as raw JSON.
mesh/repo-check pass: THE CHANGE ALTERS ITS OWN CHECK (merge-check.sh, merge-check-typescript.sh): main's version judged it; the change's judges the pull r…
A module whose dependencies could not be fetched was said NOT TESTED and the
repository check passed, so a merge on it would have landed untested code.
The build seat clones the SDK beside every check already: a forge requirement
the module cache lacks is now taken from that clone through a go.mod of its
own, and a module that still cannot be built fails the check by name and why.
A TypeScript module whose dependencies the toolchain lacks fails the same way.
A delivery's own restarts reached the operator as notifications while it ran, and every restart of the
tool runner popped the four silenced messages up again on the desk, twice. The router now reads the
controller's walk start and end on plan-moved, holds what an open walk touches until its end or bound,
tells the end as one message, and makes the restart pass once per restart from its own state, leaving
silenced, withheld, answered and held messages as they are.
The review showed the give-the-word rule skipped a failed or missing check
and group order, and let go moves nothing judged; to-be 47 has no such path.
Such a walk is now said, by stalled with walks, as held by nothing, why.
A merge whose plan sends nothing is delivered at once, yet the controller
can still open a walk for it; no live delivery then held the walk and it
waited for a person (the nzbgeek case). Give such a walk its word.
Name each held delivery in the status, and let stalled say, for every
waiting walk, what holds it, so the controller's plans line points at the
person's decision instead of a hand start.
jochen
mesh-admin
jschoubben